"What Base Text to Use for the Do Not Track Compliance Specification"
'existing controls' change proposal
'not tracking', amendment to the change proposal
'Scope' change proposal
A list of URLs relevant to today's call
Agenda for DNT Call July 17
Agenda for DNT Call July 17 -- amendment
Agenda for Wed July 24
Analysis and opinion on the DAA draft ('Tuesday homework')
audience measurement perfecting/polishing/friendly amendments
Browser finger printing?
CDDs position
Chairs' communication on next steps in the Working Group
Change Proposal - First party compliance (Issue - 170) - additional text
Change proposal: Counterproposal for a 3-state approach (R-Y-G)
Change proposal: De-identification (including unlinkability)
Change proposal: last public working draft
Change proposal: new general principle for permitted uses
- SULLIVAN, BRYAN L (Tuesday, 30 July)
- Aleecia M. McDonald (Monday, 29 July)
- SULLIVAN, BRYAN L (Monday, 29 July)
- Walter van Holst (Monday, 29 July)
- SULLIVAN, BRYAN L (Monday, 29 July)
- Chris Mejia (Friday, 26 July)
- Chris Mejia (Friday, 26 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Friday, 26 July)
- Chris Mejia (Friday, 26 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 24 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 24 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 24 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Roy T. Fielding (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 23 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Vinay Goel (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Vinay Goel (Tuesday, 23 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Monday, 22 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Monday, 22 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Monday, 22 July)
Change proposal: Proposal for a 2-state approach
Chapell - Objection to Editor's draft
Claims of DNT proliferation - Evidence?
clarifying distinctions on ISSUE-24 (security/fraud)
- Roy T. Fielding (Wednesday, 17 July)
- Peter Swire (Wednesday, 17 July)
- Roy T. Fielding (Wednesday, 17 July)
- John Simpson (Wednesday, 17 July)
- Roy T. Fielding (Wednesday, 17 July)
- Craig Spiezle (Wednesday, 17 July)
- Roy T. Fielding (Wednesday, 17 July)
- John Simpson (Wednesday, 17 July)
- Lee Tien (Tuesday, 16 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 16 July)
- Nicholas Doty (Tuesday, 16 July)
- Nicholas Doty (Tuesday, 16 July)
- Nicholas Doty (Tuesday, 16 July)
Confused by DAA's messages. Please explain
- Roy T. Fielding (Friday, 12 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Justin Brookman (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Roy T. Fielding (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Monday, 8 July)
- John Simpson (Monday, 8 July)
- David Singer (Monday, 8 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Monday, 8 July)
- David Singer (Monday, 8 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Monday, 8 July)
- Roy T. Fielding (Monday, 8 July)
- David Singer (Monday, 8 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Monday, 8 July)
- Roy T. Fielding (Monday, 8 July)
- David Singer (Sunday, 7 July)
- Roy T. Fielding (Saturday, 6 July)
- John Simpson (Friday, 5 July)
Consensus Industry Amendments to the DAA proposal
COPPA signalling
Couldn't get this submitted on Site...sending via email
DAA: please provide real examples on data change practices
De-identifed data
De-identification change proposal, comments
Definition of user agent?
DMA Objection to Editors' Draft
DNT Agenda for Wednesday, July 10
DNT Agenda for Wednesday, July 3
DNT:0 change proposal
Explanatory Memorandum
- Thomas Roessler (Monday, 22 July)
- Lauren Gelman (Monday, 22 July)
- Roy T. Fielding (Saturday, 20 July)
- Mike Zaneis (Friday, 19 July)
- Alan Chapell (Friday, 19 July)
- Thomas Roessler (Friday, 19 July)
- Shane Wiley (Friday, 19 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Friday, 19 July)
- Mike Zaneis (Friday, 19 July)
- Thomas Roessler (Thursday, 18 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 18 July)
- Thomas Roessler (Thursday, 18 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 18 July)
- Thomas Roessler (Thursday, 18 July)
- Alan Chapell (Thursday, 18 July)
- Peter Swire (Tuesday, 16 July)
extension of time on audience measurement suggested amendments
Fwd: Issue 25 Audience Measurement Research Notes and follow up from our call yesterday
Fwd: ISSUE-25 re 5.2 Audience measurement: ACTION 415 June change proposal:
Fwd: June Change Proposal: Definition of Tracking (ISSUE-5)
Fwd: procedure for posting comments today
helpful email exchanges
Industry Amendment Clarifications as Promised on July 10 W3C WG Weekly Call
- Jonathan Mayer (Saturday, 13 July)
- Justin Brookman (Saturday, 13 July)
- Lauren Gelman (Saturday, 13 July)
- Justin Brookman (Friday, 12 July)
- John Simpson (Friday, 12 July)
- Jack Hobaugh (Friday, 12 July)
- John Simpson (Friday, 12 July)
- Jack Hobaugh (Friday, 12 July)
- John Simpson (Friday, 12 July)
- Jack Hobaugh (Friday, 12 July)
Initial Work Plan on Change Proposals, including for next Wednesday
- Rob van Eijk (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Wednesday, 3 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Wednesday, 3 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Wednesday, 3 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Wednesday, 3 July)
Issue 25 Audience Measurement Research Notes and follow up from our call yesterday
ISSUE 25: ACTION 415: Audience measurement research
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 3 July)
- Justin Brookman (Wednesday, 3 July)
- Peter Swire (Wednesday, 3 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Wednesday, 3 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Tuesday, 2 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 2 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 2 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Tuesday, 2 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 2 July)
- Kathy Joe (Tuesday, 2 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Tuesday, 2 July)
- Kathy Joe (Tuesday, 2 July)
Issue for discussion on Wed
- Alan Chapell (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Edward O'Connor (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Alan Chapell (Tuesday, 9 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Shane Wiley (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Alan Chapell (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Alan Chapell (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Walter van Holst (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Alan Chapell (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Walter van Holst (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Alan Chapell (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Justin Brookman (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Alan Chapell (Tuesday, 9 July)
Issue for discussion on Wed - User Agent Compliance
- Alan Chapell (Wednesday, 17 July)
- Nicholas Doty (Tuesday, 16 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Tuesday, 16 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 16 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 16 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Monday, 15 July)
- Alan Chapell (Monday, 15 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 10 July)
- David Singer (Wednesday, 10 July)
- David Singer (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Alan Chapell (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Sid Stamm (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Justin Brookman (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Alan Chapell (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Vinay Goel (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Alan Chapell (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Sid Stamm (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Justin Brookman (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Walter van Holst (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Alan Chapell (Wednesday, 10 July)
ISSUE-151 Re: Change proposal: new general principle for permitted uses
- Chris Mejia (Monday, 29 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Monday, 29 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Monday, 29 July)
- Aleecia M. McDonald (Monday, 29 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Sunday, 28 July)
- Shane Wiley (Sunday, 28 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Sunday, 28 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Sunday, 28 July)
- Alan Chapell (Sunday, 28 July)
- Shane Wiley (Sunday, 28 July)
- Shane Wiley (Sunday, 28 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Sunday, 28 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Sunday, 28 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Sunday, 28 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Sunday, 28 July)
- Aleecia M. McDonald (Sunday, 28 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Saturday, 27 July)
- Shane Wiley (Saturday, 27 July)
- Chris Mejia (Saturday, 27 July)
- Chris Mejia (Saturday, 27 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Saturday, 27 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Saturday, 27 July)
- Chris Mejia (Saturday, 27 July)
- Chris Mejia (Saturday, 27 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Saturday, 27 July)
- Chris Mejia (Saturday, 27 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Saturday, 27 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Saturday, 27 July)
- Chris Mejia (Friday, 26 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Friday, 26 July)
- Chris Mejia (Friday, 26 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Thursday, 25 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Thursday, 25 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 25 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 24 July)
issue-199
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Edward W. Felten (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Amy Colando (LCA) (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Wednesday, 10 July)
- David Singer (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- David Singer (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Edward W. Felten (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 9 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Shane Wiley (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 3 July)
- Thomas Roessler (Monday, 1 July)
issue-205
Issue-205 for discussion on Wed - User Agent Compliance
issue-25
- Mike O'Neill (Monday, 22 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Monday, 22 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Monday, 22 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Monday, 22 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Monday, 22 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Monday, 22 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Monday, 22 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Monday, 22 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Monday, 22 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Monday, 22 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Monday, 22 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Monday, 22 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Friday, 19 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Friday, 19 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Friday, 19 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Friday, 19 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Friday, 19 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Friday, 19 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Thursday, 18 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Thursday, 18 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Thursday, 18 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Thursday, 18 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Thursday, 18 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Thursday, 18 July)
- Ronan Heffernan (Thursday, 18 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Thursday, 18 July)
ISSUE-25 re 5.2 Audience measurement: ACTION 415 June change proposal:
- Kathy Joe (Wednesday, 17 July)
- Kathy Joe (Wednesday, 17 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Kathy Joe (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Kathy Joe (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 9 July)
- JC Cannon (Tuesday, 9 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 9 July)
- JC Cannon (Tuesday, 9 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Israel, Susan (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Shane Wiley (Tuesday, 9 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Shane Wiley (Tuesday, 9 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Justin Brookman (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Shane Wiley (Tuesday, 9 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Kathy Joe (Tuesday, 9 July)
issue-25: amendment period on audience measurement
ISSUE-25: Audience measurement research : answers to questions
ISSUE-25: text to be discussed in today's call
June Change Proposal, raw data, contextual ads
June Change Proposal, tracking
June Change Proposal: Definition of Tracking (ISSUE-5)
- Peter Cranstone (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Peter Cranstone (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Lee Tien (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Edward W. Felten (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Edward W. Felten (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Thomas Roessler (Tuesday, 9 July)
- John Simpson (Tuesday, 9 July)
- achapell (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Edward W. Felten (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Thomas Roessler (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Edward W. Felten (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Shane Wiley (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Alan Chapell (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Monday, 8 July)
- David Singer (Monday, 8 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Monday, 8 July)
- David Singer (Monday, 8 July)
- David Singer (Monday, 8 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Monday, 8 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Sunday, 7 July)
- David Singer (Monday, 1 July)
June Change Proposal: Partial Compliance
June change proposal: permitted uses
June Draft - Change Proposal to definition of "Party"
June Draft - Proposal for User Agent Compliance
June Tracking Compliance and Scope Draft Change Submission
Letter from Dr. Dix (German data protection authority)
Marking the last call deadline
minutes (was Re: Path forward...)
More blocking tools than DNT
New editors draft?
next TPWG call: 4 September, usual time
Other text and DAA proposal?
Our work this week
Path forward...
Path forward... (RESPONSE REQUESTED)
- Aleecia M. McDonald (Friday, 26 July)
- Joseph Lorenzo Hall (Wednesday, 24 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 24 July)
- Aleecia M. McDonald (Wednesday, 24 July)
- Walter van Holst (Wednesday, 24 July)
- Dan Auerbach (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Alan Chapell (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Joseph Lorenzo Hall (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Chris Mejia (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Aleecia M. McDonald (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Tuesday, 23 July)
- Chris Mejia (Tuesday, 23 July)
Perfecting Amendments
procedure for posting comments today
procedure for posting comments today / reload results page if you don't see your comments
Proposed Amendments to the DAA Proposal
Proposed friendly amendments to industry draft
- Dan Auerbach (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Edward O'Connor (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Shane Wiley (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Shane Wiley (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Edward W. Felten (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Shane Wiley (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Tuesday, 9 July)
- David Singer (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Tuesday, 9 July)
- Israel, Susan (Tuesday, 9 July)
Question about DAA proposal?
Questions about DAA proposal
request measurement uses
Resignation from the Tracking Protection Working Group
Scheduling for next call
Submitters of the Industry Consensus Proposal (a.k.a. the DAA Proposal)
Supporters of DAA
text for Request for Comments/Call for Objections, with deadline this Friday
Tracking definition
tracking-ISSUE-214: Adding to last public working draft [Compliance June]
tracking-ISSUE-215: data hygiene approach / tracking of URL data and browsing activity [Compliance June]
- Jeffrey Chester (Thursday, 11 July)
- Justin Brookman (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Justin Brookman (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rigo Wenning (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Tracking Protection Working Group Issue Tracker (Wednesday, 10 July)
two general change proposals, problems
two procedural issues that came up late on Friday
Unknowing collection
URLS/scoring
- Shane Wiley (Friday, 12 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Justin Brookman (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Justin Brookman (Thursday, 11 July)
- Edward W. Felten (Thursday, 11 July)
- Justin Brookman (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Mike O'Neill (Thursday, 11 July)
- Edward W. Felten (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Jules Polonetsky (Thursday, 11 July)
- Paul Ohm (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Thursday, 11 July)
- Edward W. Felten (Thursday, 11 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Lauren Gelman (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Peter Swire (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Jeffrey Chester (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Justin Brookman (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Justin Brookman (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Justin Brookman (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Justin Brookman (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Jonathan Mayer (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Shane Wiley (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Justin Brookman (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Rob van Eijk (Wednesday, 10 July)
- Justin Brookman (Wednesday, 10 July)
Use of 1st Party Data in a 3rd Party Context
User agent vs. computer?
we need industry responses to questions raised on proposal
WED agenda
what base text to use (was re: data hygiene approach / tracking of URL data) [for auerbach]
what base text to use (was re: data hygiene approach / tracking of URL data) [for jmayer]
Work Plan for July
Last message date: Wednesday, 31 July 2013 09:25:34 UTC