public-dxwg-wg@w3.org from June 2018 by thread

Closing requirement issues on github? Antoine Isaac (Saturday, 30 June)

Closed: [dxwg] Profiles SHOULD have both both machine and human-readable views. (6.1) kcoyle via GitHub (Saturday, 30 June)

Poll for new time for the CNEG meeting Svensson, Lars (Saturday, 30 June)

Regrets for the next two plenary meetings and the next CNEG meeting Svensson, Lars (Friday, 29 June)

Re: Initial notes on profileDesc Karen Coyle (Thursday, 28 June)

DCMI/ASIS&T Webinar slides on profiles Karen Coyle (Thursday, 28 June)

New requirements on github? Antoine Isaac (Thursday, 28 June)

[DCAT] group meeting 2018-06-28 Simon.Cox@csiro.au (Thursday, 28 June)

Re: In DCAT, Is is possible to specify an void:rootResource in DCAT? Simon.Cox@csiro.au (Thursday, 28 June)

[dxwg] Add void:rootResource as property of dcat:Resource ? Simon Cox via GitHub (Thursday, 28 June)

Re: [dxwg] Related datasets [RRDS] Simon Cox via GitHub (Thursday, 28 June)

dxwg-ACTION-138: Trigger feedback from ANDS Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 28 June)

dxwg-ACTION-137: Add some notes into https://â??github.com/â??w3c/â??dxwg/â??issues/â??259 about our discussion Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 28 June)

dxwg-ACTION-136: Create issue from mailing list comment Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 28 June)

dxwg-ACTION-135: Acknowledge comment Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 28 June)

[dxwg] Pull Request: Remove minor nits left behind in copy-and-paste Simon Cox via GitHub (Thursday, 28 June)

[dxwg] Pull Request: Remove minor nits left behind in copy-and-paste Simon Cox via GitHub (Thursday, 28 June)

[DCAT] team meeting 2018-06-28 - Agenda Simon.Cox@csiro.au (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: There needs to be metadata about the views provided by profiles (“named collections of properties”) that can included in a http header [ID5] (5.5) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Invocation of a profile may be by profile name, a schema choice, an encoding, and/or a language. (schema? And assume that encoding is type as in type="application/xml".) [ID5] (5.5) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: a profiles offered by a service must be discoverable through a machine-readable graph of metadata that describes what is offered and how to invoke the offered profiles. [ID5] (5.5) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: A profile can be modular, with a given response made up of more than one module. A server can indicate that a response conforms to multiple, modular profiles. [ID3] (5.3) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: There should be a way for a client to look up additional information about a profile. (What kinds of information? Can we clarify this?) [ID2] (5.2) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: a client should be able to determine which profiles are supported by a server, and with which content types or other properties, in order to receive the one most appropriate for their use. Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: a profile must have an identifier that can be served with a response to an API or http request. [ID2] (5.2) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Profiles can have human-readable definitions of terms and input instructions [ID46] (5.46) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Profiles may provide lists of values to pick from in order to populate data elements [id46] (5.46) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Profiles can have what is needed to drive forms for data input or for user display. [ID46] (5.46) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Profiles should be able to indicate what external standards are expected to be applied/have been applied to the data provided.[ID43] (5.43) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Profiles may be written in or may link to a document or schema in a validation language (ShEx, SHACL, XMLschema). [ID41] (5.41) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Profiles may express dependencies between elements of the vocabulary (if A then not B, etc.) [ID41] (5.41) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Profiles may provide rules governing value validity [ID41] (5.41) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Profiles may provide rules on cardinality of terms (including “recommended”) [ID41] (5.41) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Profiles are "named collections of properties" or metadata terms (if not RDF) [ID41] (5.41) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: data publishers may publish data according to different profiles, either simultaneously (in one same data "distribution") or in parallel (via content negotiation). Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: a profile may be (partially) "implemented" by "schemas" (in OWL, SHACL, XML Schema...) that allow different levels of data validation Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: a profile should have human-readable documentation that expresses for humans the main components of a profile, which can also be available as machine-readable resources (ontology or schema files, SHACL files, etc). This includes listing of elements in the profile, instructions and recommendations on how to use them, constraints that determine what data is valid according to the profile, etc. Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: from the perspective of management of profiles, and guidance to users and data experts, ecosystems of profiles should be properly described (e.g. in profile catalogues/repositories), especially documenting the relationships between profiles and what they are based on, and between profiles that are based on other profiles. Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: one can create a profile of profiles, with elements (constructs, axioms…) potentially inherited on several levels Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement [derived from the previous one: it's rather trivial, but one never knows…]: profiles may or may not be "exclusive" of other profiles, i.e. some profiles may forbid the use of their elements in combination of other profiles, while others (in a typical open-world fashion) will allow such combined use. Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: a vocabulary or data model can be a profile of several other vocabularies or data models at once Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: there is a need to distinguish between distributions that package the entire dataset and those that support access to specific items, queries, and packaged downloads of data. [ID51] (5.51) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Return http link headers using the following relationship types... [ID30] (5.30) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Enable the ability to negotiate the metadata profile via http, similar to the negotiation of metadata formats today. [ID30] (5.30) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: Metadata about server profile support can be used for discovery and mediated traversal via content negotiation. [ID5] (5.5) Nicholas Car via GitHub (Wednesday, 27 June)

Re: [dxwg] DCAT - DATS alignment (profile) Simon Cox via GitHub (Tuesday, 26 June)

Re: [dxwg] DCAT - CERIF alignment (profile) makxdekkers via GitHub (Tuesday, 26 June)

Agenda June 26 Karen Coyle (Tuesday, 26 June)

[dxwg] [conneg] IETF submission must not include query param pattern requirements Rob Sanderson via GitHub (Monday, 25 June)

[dxwg] [profiledesc] role assumes closed world of the document Rob Sanderson via GitHub (Monday, 25 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by nicholascar Nicholas Car via GitHub (Monday, 25 June)

ODRL community group - and profiles Antoine Isaac (Monday, 25 June)

[dxwg] Define conneg interaction with media types that have a profile param Rob Sanderson via GitHub (Friday, 22 June)

[dxwg] Pull Request: further PROV alignment, including for mooted WebService class Nicholas Car via GitHub (Friday, 22 June)

[dxwg] How to express distributions provided as compressed files Jakob VoĂź via GitHub (Friday, 22 June)

Re: [dxwg] dcat:mediaType - check constraints Jakob VoĂź via GitHub (Friday, 22 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: A profile can be modular, with a given response made up of more than one module. A server can indicate that a response conforms to multiple, modular profiles Lars G. Svensson via GitHub (Friday, 22 June)

Re: [dxwg] A profile must be packaged as a self-contained artefact Rob Sanderson via GitHub (Thursday, 21 June)

Re: [dxwg] Responses can conform to multiple, modular profiles (UC 5.3) Rob Sanderson via GitHub (Thursday, 21 June)

Re: [dxwg] Profiles should provide both machine and human readable views (6.1) Rob Sanderson via GitHub (Thursday, 21 June)

Re: [dxwg] Profiles must support declaration of vocabulary constraints (6.1) Rob Sanderson via GitHub (Thursday, 21 June)

Re: [dxwg] Profile Composition and Languages Rob Sanderson via GitHub (Thursday, 21 June)

Re: [dxwg] Usage notes [RUN] Rob Sanderson via GitHub (Thursday, 21 June)

Re: [dxwg] Profiles listing [RPFL] Rob Sanderson via GitHub (Thursday, 21 June)

Use case/requirement ID40 Karen Coyle (Thursday, 21 June)

Fwd: Publication moratoria for second half of 2018 Karen Coyle (Thursday, 21 June)

DCAT sub-group meeting 2018-06-21 david.browning@thomsonreuters.com (Thursday, 21 June)

Minutes from the CNEG meeting 2018-06-20 Svensson, Lars (Thursday, 21 June)

dxwg-ACTION-134: Draft some text about the drivers for DCAT Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 21 June)

List of proposed new use cases Karen Coyle (Wednesday, 20 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by davebrowning David Browning via GitHub (Wednesday, 20 June)

[DCAT] Telecon2018.06.21 - Proposed agenda david.browning@thomsonreuters.com (Wednesday, 20 June)

dxwg-ACTION-133: Report back progress to plenary. Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Wednesday, 20 June)

dxwg-ACTION-132: Report back this expectation to plenary (accepting in the plenary meeting will generate action to generation pr against ucr) Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Wednesday, 20 June)

dxwg-ACTION-131: Report back this expectation to plenary (accepting in the plenary meeting will generate action to generation pr against ucr) Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Wednesday, 20 June)

[dxwg] Pull Request: Add description of relation to LDP and LDN Jakub KlĂ­mek via GitHub (Wednesday, 20 June)

Content Negotiation subgroup meetings (RE: Introduction - Rob Sanderson, J Paul Getty TrustI Svensson, Lars (Wednesday, 20 June)

Introduction - Rob Sanderson, J Paul Getty Trust Robert Sanderson (Tuesday, 19 June)

Was this Use Case ever accepted? Simon.Cox@csiro.au (Tuesday, 19 June)

New use-case - Catalogues in which dataset is a bag of files Simon.Cox@csiro.au (Tuesday, 19 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by agbeltran Alejandra Gonzalez-Beltran via GitHub (Tuesday, 19 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by agbeltran Alejandra Gonzalez-Beltran via GitHub (Tuesday, 19 June)

[dxwg] Catalogues in which dataset is a bag of files Simon Cox via GitHub (Tuesday, 19 June)

RE: [ExternalEmail] Media Types URIs - profileneg - lang Car, Nicholas (L&W, Dutton Park) (Tuesday, 19 June)

Re: [ExternalEmail] Media Types URIs - profileneg Car, Nicholas (L&W, Dutton Park) (Monday, 18 June)

Media Types URIs Car, Nicholas (L&W, Dutton Park) (Monday, 18 June)

Updates to G-Doc Karen Coyle (Monday, 18 June)

Agenda Tuesday 19 June Karen Coyle (Monday, 18 June)

Meeting details for the CNEG subgroup meeting on Wednesday, June 20 Svensson, Lars (Saturday, 16 June)

Re: [dxwg] Allow license property to link to other than LicenseDocument Nicholas Car via GitHub (Thursday, 14 June)

TPAC 2018 registration now open Coralie Mercier (Thursday, 14 June)

DCAT sub-group meeting 208-06-14 Simon.Cox@csiro.au (Thursday, 14 June)

Re: [dxwg] dcat:downloadURL - check constraints Simon Cox via GitHub (Thursday, 14 June)

Closed: [dxwg] Quality-related information [RDQIF] Simon Cox via GitHub (Thursday, 14 June)

Re: [dxwg] Quality-related information [RDQIF] Alejandra Gonzalez-Beltran via GitHub (Thursday, 14 June)

[DCAT] Telecon2018.06.14 - Dataset Exchange Working Group Simon.Cox@csiro.au (Wednesday, 13 June)

Re: [dxwg] Revision to UC19 Simon Cox via GitHub (Wednesday, 13 June)

[dxwg] Requirement: There needs to be a property in the profile where the rules for the descriptive content can be provided. This would apply to the entire profile. [ID42] (5.42) kcoyle via GitHub (Tuesday, 12 June)

dxwg-ACTION-130: Create github issue for id42 Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Tuesday, 12 June)

dxwg-ACTION-129: Create new use case and requirements for more complex situation Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Tuesday, 12 June)

Re: [dxwg] Datasets vs. Catalog relation [RDSCR] chris sweeney via GitHub (Monday, 11 June)

[dxwg] DCAT - LDP (Linked Data Platform) alignment Jakub KlĂ­mek via GitHub (Monday, 11 June)

Re: [dxwg] Adding dct:accessRights to DCAT Jakub KlĂ­mek via GitHub (Monday, 11 June)

[dxwg] Best practice for a loosely-structured catalog Jakub KlĂ­mek via GitHub (Monday, 11 June)

Re: DCAT-rev as First Public Working Draft Alejandra Gonzalez-Beltran (Sunday, 10 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by agbeltran Alejandra Gonzalez-Beltran via GitHub (Sunday, 10 June)

Agenda for plenary June 12 Karen Coyle (Saturday, 9 June)

F2F4 registration fee rates Karen Coyle (Saturday, 9 June)

[dxwg] Examples of quality for services Riccardo Albertoni via GitHub (Friday, 8 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by dr-shorthair Simon Cox via GitHub (Friday, 8 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by dr-shorthair Simon Cox via GitHub (Friday, 8 June)

Re: [dxwg] Remove one instance of "government" Simon Cox via GitHub (Friday, 8 June)

Re: [dxwg] Add Czech translation to dcat.ttl Simon Cox via GitHub (Friday, 8 June)

Best practice for a loosely-structured catalog? Simon.Cox@csiro.au (Friday, 8 June)

Re: ACTION-128: Re-write requirement: profiles should be able to indicate what external standards are expected to be applied to the data provided. [id42, id43] (5.42, 5.43) [profile] (Dataset Exchange Working Group) Karen Coyle (Thursday, 7 June)

Re: [dxwg] dcat:accessURL - check constraints Simon Cox via GitHub (Thursday, 7 June)

[dxwg] DCAT - schema.org alignment (profile) Simon Cox via GitHub (Thursday, 7 June)

[DCAT] - Draft agenda telecon 2018-06-07 Simon.Cox@csiro.au (Wednesday, 6 June)

Re: [dxwg] Added a section to deal with quality and started some guidance for r… Simon Cox via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by dr-shorthair Simon Cox via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

Re: ACTION-127: Re-write requirement from id46 "profiles can have rules for data value validation, including pick lists [id46] (5.46) [profile]" (Dataset Exchange Working Group) Antoine Isaac (Tuesday, 5 June)

dxwg-ACTION-128: Re-write requirement: profiles should be able to indicate what external standards are expected to be applied to the data provided. [id42, id43] (5.42, 5.43) [profile] Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Tuesday, 5 June)

dxwg-ACTION-127: Re-write requirement from id46 "profiles can have rules for data value validation, including pick lists [id46] (5.46) [profile]" Dataset Exchange Working Group Issue Tracker (Tuesday, 5 June)

Re: ACTION-120: Add requirements to the europeana use case (Dataset Exchange Working Group) Antoine Isaac (Tuesday, 5 June)

Re: ACTION-126: Prepare a proposal for issue 57 about quality information (Dataset Exchange Working Group) Riccardo Albertoni (Tuesday, 5 June)

Re: [dxwg] Profiles must support discoverability via search engines (UC 5.40) aisaac via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

Closed: [dxwg] vann:usageNote used incorrectly in DCAT RDF representation Alejandra Gonzalez-Beltran via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

Re: [dxwg] vann:usageNote used incorrectly in DCAT RDF representation Alejandra Gonzalez-Beltran via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by agbeltran Alejandra Gonzalez-Beltran via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by davebrowning David Browning via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

[dxwg] Pull Request: dcat:keyword - Remove sub-property axiom for consistency with document Simon Cox via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

[dxwg] Pull Request: Replace vann:usageNote with skos:scopeNote Simon Cox via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

[dxwg] Pull Request: dcat:keyword - Remove sub-property axiom for consistency with document Simon Cox via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

Re: [dxwg] Distribution schema [RDIS] Simon Cox via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

Re: [dxwg] Distribution definition [RDIDF] Simon Cox via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

[dxwg] Incorrect type for *URL properties - should be owl:DatatypeProperty with range xsd:anyURI Simon Cox via GitHub (Tuesday, 5 June)

Re: [dxwg] Profiles have URI identifiers that resolve to more detailed descriptions (6.1) Andrea Perego via GitHub (Monday, 4 June)

Re: [dxwg] Qualified forms [RQF] Andrea Perego via GitHub (Monday, 4 June)

Re: [dxwg] Licenses/rights/obligations on Services Andrea Perego via GitHub (Monday, 4 June)

Re: [dxwg] Extending DCAT for services pwin via GitHub (Monday, 4 June)

Re: [dxwg] Entailment of schema.org [RES] Simon Cox via GitHub (Monday, 4 June)

RE: ACTION-125: Coordinate qualified relations topics (Dataset Exchange Working Group) Simon.Cox@csiro.au (Sunday, 3 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by dr-shorthair Simon Cox via GitHub (Sunday, 3 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by dr-shorthair Simon Cox via GitHub (Sunday, 3 June)

[dxwg] new commits pushed by dr-shorthair Simon Cox via GitHub (Sunday, 3 June)

Re: [dxwg] Provenance information [RPIF] Nicholas Car via GitHub (Saturday, 2 June)

Re: [dxwg] Use case: web browser navigation of profile information Nicholas Car via GitHub (Saturday, 2 June)

Closed: [dxwg] ID49 created - dataset business context / 'Project' class Simon Cox via GitHub (Saturday, 2 June)

Re: [dxwg] profileDesc and the Guidance document kcoyle via GitHub (Saturday, 2 June)

Re: [dxwg] Profile negotiation [RPFN] Annette Greiner via GitHub (Friday, 1 June)

Plenary agenda June 5 Karen Coyle (Friday, 1 June)

Last message date: Saturday, 30 June 2018 16:40:47 UTC