[PAQ] editorial issues
[PAQ] rel="me"
[paq] using anchor or different links
[Spam:***** SpamScore] Re: formal semantics strawman
call for new question ideas for the 2nd implementation stakeholder questionnaire
CIDOC-CRM Ontology
closing issues for the Model Document
Connection Task Force Conference Call
cross-referencing constraints in conceptual model and formal model
Dates for second F2F
defining shortcuts and extensions
Discussion focus for the next two weeks
formal semantics strawman
Guidelines for the Connection Task Force Report
ISSUE-83: Express inverse relationships in Provenance Model as well as ontology
Meeting minutes 2011-08-04
Minutes from July 28, 2011 Telecon
Minutes of Aug. 11 2011 Telecon
name of standards - responses
naming the standard
PAQ closing issues
PAQ document update, target renamed as context
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 25 August)
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 25 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 22 August)
- Olaf Hartig (Sunday, 21 August)
- Olaf Hartig (Sunday, 21 August)
- Graham Klyne (Saturday, 20 August)
- Yogesh Simmhan (Friday, 19 August)
- Graham Klyne (Friday, 19 August)
- Graham Klyne (Friday, 19 August)
- Olaf Hartig (Thursday, 18 August)
- Olaf Hartig (Thursday, 18 August)
- Yogesh Simmhan (Thursday, 18 August)
- Graham Klyne (Wednesday, 17 August)
PAQ: further revision of simple HTTP interface for discovery (ISSUE 53)
PAQ: revised section on querying
playing with pil ontology
- Daniel Garijo (Thursday, 25 August)
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 25 August)
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 25 August)
- Luc Moreau (Thursday, 25 August)
- Daniel Garijo (Wednesday, 24 August)
- Simon Miles (Wednesday, 24 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Daniel Garijo (Sunday, 21 August)
- Graham Klyne (Friday, 19 August)
- Daniel Garijo (Wednesday, 17 August)
- Graham Klyne (Wednesday, 17 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 16 August)
- Satya Sahoo (Tuesday, 16 August)
- Daniel Garijo (Tuesday, 16 August)
- Deus, Helena (Tuesday, 16 August)
- Graham Klyne (Tuesday, 16 August)
- Daniel Garijo (Monday, 15 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 15 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 15 August)
- Daniel Garijo (Monday, 15 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 15 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 15 August)
- Satya Sahoo (Monday, 15 August)
- Deus, Helena (Monday, 15 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Friday, 12 August)
- Jim McCusker (Friday, 12 August)
- Paul Groth (Thursday, 11 August)
- Deus, Helena (Thursday, 11 August)
Possible regrets (was: Telecon Agenda Aug 18, 2011)
Prov WG Telecon Agenda 04 August 2011
PROV-ISSUE-26 (uses and generates questions): How can one figure out the provenance of a given entity?
- Myers, Jim (Friday, 5 August)
- Graham Klyne (Friday, 5 August)
- Reza B'far (Friday, 5 August)
- Graham Klyne (Friday, 5 August)
- Paulo Pinheiro da Silva (Friday, 5 August)
- Luc Moreau (Friday, 5 August)
- Luc Moreau (Friday, 5 August)
- Luc Moreau (Friday, 5 August)
- Paulo Pinheiro da Silva (Friday, 5 August)
- Reza B'Far (Friday, 5 August)
- Myers, Jim (Friday, 5 August)
- Reza B'Far (Thursday, 4 August)
- Luc Moreau (Thursday, 4 August)
PROV-ISSUE-32: Bob definition [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-33: Section 3.1 and Section 3.2: example of IVPof [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-35: Section 4: How one would know that two BOBs are characterizations of the same entity? [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-39 (generation-identifiable-activity): Generation should be defined as an identifable activity [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-40 (recommended-roles): Roles should not be SHOULD and not MUST [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-41 (distinct-roles): Distinct roles should be SHOULD and not MUST [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-43 (derivation-time): Deriviation should have associated time [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-44 (shortcuts): Introduce widely used provenance concepts as shortcuts in the model [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-45: isDerivedFrom and IVPof are transitive. [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-46 (where-is-D-in-provenance): Where do I find document D in provenance [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-48 (Provenance Concept: Revision): Revision should be a class and not a property [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-51 (asserter-def): Asserter needs to be defined with respect to a provenance container/account [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-53 (sparql-query-is-overkill): can't we have a lighter method to retrieve provenance-uri, given a document uri? [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-55 (are-provenance-uris-needed): Are provenance URIs really needed [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-56 (derivation-definition-does-not-imply-transitivity): Derivation as defined is not transitive [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-57 (comment-on-ivp-of): comment on ivp of
PROV-ISSUE-58 (time-iso8601): is reference to iso8601 appropriate? [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-59 (generation-definition): on generation [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-60: comments on bob [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-61 (is-revision-necessary): is revision necessary? [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-62 (about-prov-language): about provenance language [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-64 (definition-use): definition of use [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-65 (domain-specific-info): How is domain specific data combined with the generic model [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-66 (is-execution-a-bob): Why is process execution not defined as a characterised entity? [Conceptual Model]
- Simon Miles (Wednesday, 31 August)
- Luc Moreau (Thursday, 25 August)
- Simon Miles (Thursday, 25 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 August)
- Satya Sahoo (Friday, 5 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 2 August)
- Satya Sahoo (Tuesday, 2 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 2 August)
- Satya Sahoo (Tuesday, 2 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 1 August)
- Simon Miles (Monday, 1 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Simon Miles (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Simon Miles (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
PROV-ISSUE-67 (single-execution): What is a PE? (was) Why is there a difference in what is represented by one vs multiple executions? [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-67 (single-execution): Why is there a difference in what is represented by one vs multiple executions? [Conceptual Model]
- Simon Miles (Thursday, 25 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 August)
- Myers, Jim (Saturday, 6 August)
- Satya Sahoo (Friday, 5 August)
- Myers, Jim (Friday, 5 August)
- Simon Miles (Friday, 5 August)
- Graham Klyne (Friday, 5 August)
- Myers, Jim (Friday, 5 August)
- Simon Miles (Friday, 5 August)
- Myers, Jim (Friday, 5 August)
- Luc Moreau (Friday, 5 August)
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 4 August)
- Simon Miles (Thursday, 4 August)
- Myers, Jim (Thursday, 4 August)
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 4 August)
- Myers, Jim (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Luc Moreau (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Luc Moreau (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Simon Miles (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Myers, Jim (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Myers, Jim (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Paolo Missier (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Myers, Jim (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Luc Moreau (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Myers, Jim (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Paolo Missier (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 2 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 2 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 1 August)
- Simon Miles (Monday, 1 August)
- Paul Groth (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Simon Miles (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
PROV-ISSUE-68 (http-link-domain): Domain of HTTP links with rel=provenance [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-69 (Process Execution): Process execution occurs over a "continuous time interval"? [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-70 (provenance-term): PAQ document uses inconsistent terminology for "provenance"
PROV-ISSUE-71 (Conceptual Model draft): Section 3.2 of Conceptual Model draft (Content and Editing) [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-72 (DGarijo): Uses should be renamed as used [Formal Model]
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 25 August)
- Ralph Hodgson (Wednesday, 24 August)
- Simon Miles (Wednesday, 24 August)
- Deborah L. McGuinness (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Satya Sahoo (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Daniel Garijo (Monday, 22 August)
- Ralph Hodgson (Monday, 22 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 August)
- Ralph Hodgson (Monday, 22 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 August)
- Simon Miles (Thursday, 11 August)
- Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 11 August)
PROV-ISSUE-73: Use "anchor" context URI instead of introducing a "target" relationship in HTTP [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-74: Consider renaming target-uri as context-uri to be consistent with RFC 5988 [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-75 (provenance-service-and-provenance-uri): What do we do when we get both provenance service and provenance-uri? [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-76 (xml-examples): Shouldn't we have proper examples in XML and not RDF/XML [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-77 (paq-terminology): terminology issues [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-78 (contexts-and-provenance-uris): multiple contexts and provenance-uris [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-79 (provenance-uri-contract): what is the contract associated with provenance-uris [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-80 (about-provenance-template): Query about provenance template [Accessing and Querying Provenance]
PROV-ISSUE-81 (identity-clash-scope): In a given scope, are entities with same identifier but different attributes legal? [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-82 (pidm-event): Should we introduce a notion of event in the data model? [Conceptual Model]
PROV-ISSUE-84 (namespace-for-properties): What should namespace for properties be? [Formal Model]
PROV-WG Telecon Agenda 01 Sep 2011
PROV-WG Telecon Agenda 25 August 2011
Provenance context URIs for RDF data (was: PAQ document update, target renamed as context)
provenance model document
Provenance model document is over-complicated and hard to understand
Provenance requirements for RDF named graphs
Regrets ...
regrets for telecon 8/18, 8/25, and stakeholder questionnaire status update
relation <--> property
scribe required for teleconference
Straw Poll - Naming the Provenance Standard
Telecon Agenda Aug 11, 2011
Telecon Agenda Aug 18, 2011
test message please ignore
Updated stakeholders survey on wiki, need to compile list of communities to inform when survey goes live
updates to PAQ doc for discussion
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 25 August)
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 25 August)
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 25 August)
- Graham Klyne (Thursday, 25 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Paul Groth (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Simon Miles (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 23 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 22 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 22 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 22 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 22 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Monday, 22 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Monday, 22 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Monday, 22 August)
- Myers, Jim (Saturday, 20 August)
- Graham Klyne (Saturday, 20 August)
- Myers, Jim (Friday, 19 August)
- Graham Klyne (Friday, 19 August)
- Myers, Jim (Friday, 19 August)
- Graham Klyne (Friday, 19 August)
- Myers, Jim (Friday, 19 August)
- Graham Klyne (Friday, 19 August)
- Myers, Jim (Wednesday, 17 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Wednesday, 17 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Wednesday, 17 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 16 August)
- Graham Klyne (Tuesday, 16 August)
- Graham Klyne (Tuesday, 16 August)
- Paul Groth (Tuesday, 16 August)
- Myers, Jim (Tuesday, 16 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 15 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 15 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 15 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 15 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 15 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 15 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 15 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 15 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 15 August)
- Graham Klyne (Monday, 15 August)
- Paul Groth (Sunday, 14 August)
- Myers, Jim (Sunday, 14 August)
- Simon Miles (Sunday, 14 August)
- Paul Groth (Friday, 12 August)
- Myers, Jim (Friday, 12 August)
- Paul Groth (Friday, 12 August)
- Myers, Jim (Thursday, 11 August)
- Paul Groth (Thursday, 11 August)
- Myers, Jim (Thursday, 11 August)
- Yogesh Simmhan (Thursday, 11 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Thursday, 11 August)
- Paul Groth (Wednesday, 10 August)
views, complements and invariants (was: updates to PAQ doc for discussion)
vote on replacement for BOB (deadline: Wednesday 03 Aug 8am GMT)
- Satya Sahoo (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Stephan Zednik (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Jim McCusker (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Deus, Helena (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Khalid Belhajjame (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Olaf Hartig (Wednesday, 3 August)
- Daniel Garijo (Tuesday, 2 August)
- Reza B'Far (Tuesday, 2 August)
- Cresswell, Stephen (Tuesday, 2 August)
- Curt Tilmes (Tuesday, 2 August)
- Carl Reed (Monday, 1 August)
- Ryan Golden (Monday, 1 August)
- Timothy Lebo (Monday, 1 August)
- Satya Sahoo (Monday, 1 August)
- Paul Groth (Monday, 1 August)
- Timothy Lebo (Monday, 1 August)
- Timothy Lebo (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
- Paul Groth (Monday, 1 August)
- Timothy Lebo (Monday, 1 August)
- Myers, Jim (Monday, 1 August)
- Simon Dobson (Monday, 1 August)
- Luc Moreau (Monday, 1 August)
Weekly Connection Task Force Call - each Monday
Last message date: Wednesday, 31 August 2011 17:35:27 UTC