public-prov-wg@w3.org from October 2012 by thread

Reminder: Review of responses to PROV-CONSTRAINTS public comments James Cheney (Wednesday, 31 October)

PROV WG Telecon 2012.11.01 Luc Moreau (Wednesday, 31 October)

RE: PROV-ISSUE-410 (prov-primer-review): Feedback on Primer document [Primer] Miles, Simon (Tuesday, 30 October)

Re: Provenance Example for TriG Spec Paul Groth (Tuesday, 30 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-475: Request to drop "mention" and related elements [prov-dm] Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 30 October)

Updates to PROV-XML Note draft. Stephan Zednik (Tuesday, 30 October)

RE: Comments on the Prov Primer Miles, Simon (Monday, 29 October)

prov-wg: Vote on Exit Criteria Paul Groth (Monday, 29 October)

Review of PROV-CONSTRAINTS issues (ISSUE-576, ISSUE-580, ISSUE-577, ISSUE-578, ISSUE-581) James Cheney (Monday, 29 October)

prov-wg draft agenda F2F4 Paul Groth (Saturday, 27 October)

confirmation on changes to prov-n Paul Groth (Saturday, 27 October)

prov-wg Minutes of the October 25, 2012 Telcon Paul Groth (Saturday, 27 October)

Re: typo "addiition" in prov-o 3.1 editor's draft Timothy Lebo (Friday, 26 October)

Review of PROV-CONSTRAINTS issues (ISSUE-582, ISSUE-579, ISSUE-585, ISSUE-583) James Cheney (Friday, 26 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-556 (time-qualification): public comment: should qualfied and unqualified versions the same [prov-dm-constraints] Paul Groth (Friday, 26 October)

further responses and closed issues in prov-dm Luc Moreau (Friday, 26 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-556 (time-qualification): public comment: should qualfied and unqualified versions the same [prov-dm-constraints] James Cheney (Friday, 26 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-560: type overlap question [prov-dm-constraints] James Cheney (Friday, 26 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-559: For delegation, two agents need to have some overlap in their lifetime. [prov-dm-constraints] James Cheney (Friday, 26 October)

Review of PROV_CONSTRAINTS issues (ISSUE-582, ISSUE-586, ISSUE-587, ISSUE-588) James Cheney (Friday, 26 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-490 (prov-constraints-lc-editorial): PROV-CONSTRAINTS pre-Last Call editorial issues [prov-dm-constraints] James Cheney (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-588 (strictly-precedes-irreflexive): It is never specified explicitly that "strictly-precedes" is irreflexive [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-587 (rdf-analogies): Concerns about analogies to RDF blank nodes/semantics [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-586 (toplevel-bundle-description): The description of 'toplevel bundle' as 'set of statements not appearing in a named bundle' is unclear [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-585 (applying-satisfying-constraints): Suggestion to avoid discussing how to 'apply' constraints; clarify what it means to 'satisfy' constraints [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-584 (merging): The nonstandard/procedurally defined 'merging' operation on terms [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-583 (equivalent-instances-in-bundles): Questions concerning what it means for applications to treat equivalent instances 'in the same way', particularly in bundles. [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-582 (document-instance): 'of their respective documents.' should be '... of their respective instances.' [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-581 (avoid-specifying-algorithm): Suggestion to avoid wording that 'almost requires' using normalization to implement constraints [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-580 (drop-syntactic-sugar-definitions): Suggestion to drop definitions in section 4.1 since they are not needed if the semantics is defined more abstractly [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-579 (declarative-fol-specification): Suggestion to replace procedural specification with (equivalent, but shorter and less prescriptive) declarative theory in First-Order Logic [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-578 (equivalence): Use of "equivalent" incompatible with common uses of the term in logic/mathematics [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

PROV-ISSUE-577 (valid-vs-consistent): Terminology: valid vs. consistent [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 25 October)

Syntax checking Turtle examples (ACTION-117) Stian Soiland-Reyes (Thursday, 25 October)

Fwd: activity delegation (ISSUE-522) Luc Moreau (Thursday, 25 October)

Re: acknowledging PROV responses (ISSUE-516) Luc Moreau (Thursday, 25 October)

on specialization/alternate/membership (ISSUE-525) Luc Moreau (Thursday, 25 October)

closing some prov-dm issues Luc Moreau (Thursday, 25 October)

prov-wg: Telcon Agenda October 25, 2012 Paul Groth (Wednesday, 24 October)

prov-wg: Minutes of the October 18, 2012 Telecon Paul Groth (Tuesday, 23 October)

last call for comments on exit criteria Paul Groth (Tuesday, 23 October)

PROV-ISSUE-576: logical definition and comments on prov-constratins [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Tuesday, 23 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-472 (Feedback_IH): Review of the DC-NOTE by Ivan Herman [Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core] Daniel Garijo (Tuesday, 23 October)

Re: proposed responses to public comments (deadline Wednesday 24th, midnight GMT) Paul Groth (Tuesday, 23 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-402 (Feedback_SM): Feedback on the feedback from Simon Miles [Mapping PROV-O to Dublin Core] Daniel Garijo (Monday, 22 October)

proposed responses to public comments (deadline Wednesday 24th, midnight GMT) Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 October)

ISSUE-475: Request to drop "mention" and related elements Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-495: ivan's feedback on prov-dm LC [prov-dm] Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-463 (freimuth): comments from robert freimuth [prov-dm] Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-498: Data Model Table 2 [prov-dm] Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-462 (entity-definition-precision): Definition o entity may be too liberal [prov-dm] Luc Moreau (Monday, 22 October)

PROV-ISSUE-575: identifier field [prov-dm-constraints] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Monday, 22 October)

Revised Exit Criteria - final comments Paul Groth (Friday, 19 October)

pairs of implementations? Paul Groth (Friday, 19 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-446: prov:involvee not documented in PROV-O [PROV-O HTML] Daniel Garijo (Friday, 19 October)

[PROV-O] Proposed OWL change: Dealing with Issue 568 (hadRole) Daniel Garijo (Friday, 19 October)

scribe needed Paul Groth (Thursday, 18 October)

RDF WG responses Ivan Herman (Thursday, 18 October)

Fwd: clock change reminder; 28-Oct to 4-Nov Ivan Herman (Thursday, 18 October)

PROV-WG telcon minutes Luc Moreau (Thursday, 18 October)

2nd CFP: BigPROV @EDBT 2013 and ProvBench: Managing and Querying Provenance Data at Scale Paolo Missier (Wednesday, 17 October)

Test cases for PROV-CONSTRAINTS Huynh T.D. (Wednesday, 17 October)

prov-n issues under review Paul Groth (Wednesday, 17 October)

prov-dm issues under review Paul Groth (Wednesday, 17 October)

prov-wg Telcon Agenda Oct. 18, 2012 Paul Groth (Wednesday, 17 October)

reminder about prov exit criteria Paul Groth (Wednesday, 17 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-499: Data Model Section 2.1.1, semantics [prov-dm] Paul Groth (Wednesday, 17 October)

Re: Primary Source again (Re: PROV-ISSUE-518: Data Model Section 5.2.4 ) [prov-dm] Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 16 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-499: Data Model Section 2.1.1, semantics [prov-dm] Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 16 October)

PROV-ISSUE-574 (primer-figure): Update primer overview figure [Primer] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Tuesday, 16 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-496: ivan's feedback on prov-n LC [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 16 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-477 (rename toplevel-bundle): rename toplevel-bundle to dataset [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 16 October)

prov-n proposed responses to comments (deadline Thursday 12noon GMT) Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-544: Notation Section 3.7 [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

PROV-ISSUE-573 (mime-type): mime type registration feedback [prov-n] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-539: Notation Section 3, EBNF format [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-540: Notation Section 3, structure of documentation [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-533: Notation, of attributes [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-538: Notation Section 2.4, example 2 [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-536: Notation Section 2.3 [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-534: Notation Section 2.1 [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-535: Notation Section 2.2 [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-537: Notation Section 2.4 [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-545: Notation Section 3.7.2 [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-546: Notation Section 3.7.4 [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-543: Notation Section 3.5 [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-541: Notation Section 3.1.3 [prov-n] Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Fwd: New public IRC server refuses passwords Ivan Herman (Monday, 15 October)

prov-n issues closed Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

proposed responses to public comments (deadline: Wednesday 10/17) Luc Moreau (Monday, 15 October)

Admin for the F2F: please make sure you register Ivan Herman (Friday, 12 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-572: What constraints should we have on ordering of elements within the main complexTypes? [XML Serialization] Paul Groth (Friday, 12 October)

alternate of and sambas Paul Groth (Thursday, 11 October)

scribe required for today, thanks! Luc Moreau (Thursday, 11 October)

Revised exit criteria Paul Groth (Thursday, 11 October)

PROV-ISSUE-572: What constraints should we have on ordering of elements within the main complexTypes? [XML Serialization] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Thursday, 11 October)

Dealing with mutable resources (PROV-O in Callimachus) - ISSUE-569 Paul Groth (Wednesday, 10 October)

PROV-ISSUE-570 (changing resources): How do we deal with resources that change? [prov-dm] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Wednesday, 10 October)

PROV-ISSUE-571 (changing resources): How do we deal with resources that change? [prov-dm] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Wednesday, 10 October)

PROV-ISSUE-569 (changing resources): How do we deal with resources that change? [prov-dm] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Wednesday, 10 October)

Presentation on Prov yesterday Ivan Herman (Wednesday, 10 October)

Provenance specs: have we lost sight of the goal? Graham Klyne (Tuesday, 9 October)

PROV-WG Telecon Agenda 10 October 2012 Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 9 October)

prov-wg Telcon Minutes October 4, 2012 Paul Groth (Tuesday, 9 October)

RE: PROV-ISSUE-563 (primer-alternates-figure): Primer Section 3.9 Alternates [Primer] Miles, Simon (Tuesday, 9 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-482: [external question] bundle IDs on insertion, context [prov-dm] Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 9 October)

Re: prov-dm normative sections (ISSUE-495) Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 9 October)

feedback sought on ISSUE-529, ISSUE-524, ISSUE5-519, ISSUE-523 Luc Moreau (Tuesday, 9 October)

proposed responses to public comments (deadline: Wednesday 10/10) Luc Moreau (Monday, 8 October)

PROV-ISSUE-568 (hadRole-domain): domain of prov:hadRole [Ontology] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Monday, 8 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-565 (rdfa-check): Do the suggested way of pointing to provenance work in rdfa [Accessing and Querying Provenance] Graham Klyne (Saturday, 6 October)

RE: PROV-ISSUE-515: Data Model Section 5.1.8 [prov-dm] Freimuth, Robert, Ph.D. (Wednesday, 3 October)

RE: PROV-ISSUE-530: Data Model Section 5.7.2 (Table 6) [prov-dm] Freimuth, Robert, Ph.D. (Wednesday, 3 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-520: Data Model Section 5.3.1 [prov-dm] Paul Groth (Wednesday, 3 October)

RE: PROV-ISSUE-520: Data Model Section 5.3.1 [prov-dm] Freimuth, Robert, Ph.D. (Wednesday, 3 October)

RE: PROV-ISSUE-521: Data Model Section 5.3.3 [prov-dm] Freimuth, Robert, Ph.D. (Wednesday, 3 October)

prov-wg - Telcon Agenda October 3, 2012 Paul Groth (Wednesday, 3 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-522: Data Model Section 5.3.4 [prov-dm] Khalid Belhajjame (Wednesday, 3 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-513: Data Model Section 5.1.6 [prov-dm] Khalid Belhajjame (Wednesday, 3 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-516: Data Model Section 5.2.1 [prov-dm] Khalid Belhajjame (Wednesday, 3 October)

Re: batch 3 (18 issues): proposed responses to public comments (deadline Wednesday Oct 3rd) Paul Groth (Wednesday, 3 October)

UML and upper case labels Paul Groth (Wednesday, 3 October)

subactivity resolutions Paul Groth (Wednesday, 3 October)

ISSUE-520 response Paul Groth (Wednesday, 3 October)

PROV-ISSUE-567 (Link-to-inverse-prop-missing): The link ti the inverse property file is missing in the ontology [PROV-O HTML] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Tuesday, 2 October)

PROV-ISSUE-566 (fix-images): HTML images still have references to the bundles as named greaphs [PROV-O HTML] Provenance Working Group Issue Tracker (Monday, 1 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-565 (rdfa-check): Do the suggested way of pointing to provenance work in rdfa [Accessing and Querying Provenance] Paul Groth (Monday, 1 October)

Re: PROV-ISSUE-565 (rdfa-check): Do the suggested way of pointing to provenance work in rdfa [Accessing and Querying Provenance] Ivan Herman (Monday, 1 October)

Re: Editorial error in the primer Ivan Herman (Monday, 1 October)

Last message date: Wednesday, 31 October 2012 18:03:08 UTC