www-patentpolicy-comment@w3.org from January 2003 by author

Adam Warner

• W3C Royalty-Free Patent Policy Last Call Working Draft Comment (Monday, 30 December)

Adrián De León

• Comments on the W3C patent policy (Sunday, 12 January)

Alan Chandler

• Approval of draft policy on Software Patenting (Tuesday, 31 December)

Alex Borges (lex)

• Disagree with the "field of use" restriction (Sunday, 12 January)
• Disagree with the "field of use" restriction (Tuesday, 31 December)

Alex Jacques

• Urge approval of draft policy (Wednesday, 29 January)

Alexander Schmehl

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting. (Tuesday, 31 December)

Andre Lehovich

• adopt royalty-free draft policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Andrea Borgia

• please remove "fields-of-use" restrictions (Tuesday, 31 December)

Andres L. Figari

• W3C's proposed patent policy. (Tuesday, 31 December)

Andrew Moise

• Partially royalty-free patents (Tuesday, 31 December)

Andy Farnsworth

• Proposed patent Policy problem - i.e. Field of Use clause (Tuesday, 31 December)

Arno Peters

• Comments on patent policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Arpad Biro

• Comment: Free Software Community (Tuesday, 31 December)

Arvan Reese

• re:FSF's Position on Proposed W3 Consortium "Royalty-Free" Patent Policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Asheesh Laroia

• W3 Policy: Up with draft, down with software patents (Monday, 6 January)

atmcneil@earthlink.net

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting (Tuesday, 31 December)

B. Chandler

• comment (Tuesday, 31 December)

Ben North

• Objection to "field of use" restriction (Tuesday, 7 January)

Benjamin Johnson

• Re: Royalty-Free Patent Policy correction (Tuesday, 31 December)
• Royalty-Free Patent Policy correction (Tuesday, 31 December)

bill@wadley.org

• I believe (Monday, 30 December)

Brett Smith

• Comments about the proposed patent policy (Wednesday, 1 January)

Brian

• Open Source Licencing and Patent encumbrance (Tuesday, 31 December)

Brian Gough

• objection to field of use restrictions (Monday, 30 December)

Brock Frazier

• Draft policy not ideal but acceptable (Tuesday, 31 December)

Bruce Badger

• FSF position on Section 3 (Monday, 30 December)

Bruce Perens

• SPI response to Microsoft comment of January 16. (Sunday, 19 January)

Bryan

• comment on current draft of W3C patent policy (Monday, 30 December)

C. Conrad Cady

• Royalty Free Patent Policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Charles

• And about freedom? (Tuesday, 31 December)

Chris Seager

• I object to the "Royalty-Free" Patent Policy. (Tuesday, 31 December)

Christopher Hicks

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting. (Tuesday, 31 December)

Clark McGrew

• Section 3.3 (Monday, 30 December)

Colin Bell

• The Future of the W3C (Patent Policy) (Tuesday, 31 December)

Cory Trese

• Comments: W3C Royalty-Free Patent Policy Last Call Working Draft (Tuesday, 31 December)

D F

• Re: MS views on Last Call Patent Policy Draft (Saturday, 25 January)
• W3C Draft Policy on Royalty-Free Patents (Tuesday, 31 December)

Daliel Leite

• "field of use" (Tuesday, 31 December)

Daniel Weitzner

• archive system bug (Thursday, 2 January)

Dave McFadden

• So-called Patent Policy "bug" of Section 3.3 (Tuesday, 31 December)

Dave Owen (Los Angeles)

• Item 3 of Section 3: W3C Royalty-Free (RF) Licensing Requirements (Monday, 30 December)

David Allouche

• Do not accept "field of use" restriction (Tuesday, 31 December)

David GLAUDE Mailing

• Comment on section 3 item 3. (Tuesday, 31 December)

David Kaufman

• Comments: the "field of use" restrictions in Section 3 Item 3 of the proposed W3C Patents Policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

David Teague

• Pass W3C Patent Policy (Sunday, 5 January)

David Turner

• MS views on Last Call Patent Policy Draft (Thursday, 16 January)

Denis Braekhus

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting. (Thursday, 2 January)

Denton_Sam@emc.com

• W3C Royalty-Free Patent Policy Last Call (Tuesday, 31 December)

DFox

• Comments: the "field of use" restrictions (Tuesday, 31 December)

Doran Barton

• Prohibit the imposition of "field of use" restrictions on patent claims contributed to W3C standards (Tuesday, 31 December)

Doug Winter

• Field of use provision (Tuesday, 31 December)

dtwarnick@mmm.com

• Please keep the standards open and patent free (Tuesday, 31 December)

Ed Allen Smith

• Rutgers and VoiceXML - please do your best _not_ to give Rutgers (Wednesday, 29 January)

Edward Welbourne

• patent policy (Tuesday, 31 December)
• Patent Policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

elka@gnosistem.com

• Royalty-Free Patent Policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Emile van Bergen

• Support draft policy; Open Source implementations are essential (Tuesday, 31 December)

Eric M. Hopper

• A response to Microsoft's carefully worded letter (Saturday, 18 January)

Francis Smit

• Royalty-Free Patent Policy (Monday, 30 December)

Freedom Advocate

• Section 3, Item 3 (Friday, 3 January)

Geert Stappers

• no limits (Tuesday, 31 December)

Gene Heskett

• proposed web standards (Monday, 30 December)

Gervase Markham

• Comments on Microsoft's views (Saturday, 18 January)
• So nearly there... (Sunday, 29 December)
• [Resend] So nearly there... (Friday, 3 January)

Hubbard, Marc

• [www-patentpolicy-comment] <none> (Monday, 13 January)

Håkon Wium Lie

• Last call: Royalty-Free Patent Policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Jacob Kjome

• no loopholes! (Tuesday, 31 December)

James Bromberger

• Please approve draft policy; disapprove of software patents. (Tuesday, 31 December)

James Nachlin

• Patent Policy - I disapprove of software patents (Tuesday, 31 December)

James Salsman

• patentholders have failed; please fix section 3, items 3 and 7 (Monday, 30 December)

Jason Bechtel

• W3C Patent Policy Feedback (Tuesday, 31 December)

Jason Lee

• Comments for the 'field of use' restriction in Section 3, Item 3 of proposed W3C patents policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Jason Lunz

• royalty-free for web-only use is a dangerous and unwise limitation (Monday, 30 December)

Jay Sulzberger

• Against Item 3 of Section 3 of the proposed Policy on Patents (Friday, 3 January)

Jeff Michel

• Field of use conflict between section 3 item 3 and the GPL (Tuesday, 31 December)

Jerry Asher

• How free becomes too costly (Monday, 30 December)

Jesper Juhl

• Comments on 'W3C Royalty-Free Patent Policy Last Call Working Draft' (Tuesday, 31 December)

Jim Bray

• No 'field of use' patent restrictions (Monday, 30 December)

jlnance@intrex.net

• Comments on patent policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Joachim Achtzehnter

• Section 3(3) needs to be amended (Tuesday, 31 December)

Joe Gasiorek

• final call (Monday, 30 December)

John Dalton

• Please ensure patent policy is GPL compliant (Tuesday, 31 December)

John K. Hohm

• Draft Patent Policy Comment (Tuesday, 31 December)

John Pisini

• Approve of draft disapprove of software patenting. (Tuesday, 14 January)

jonathon

• Bug in the proposed draft (Tuesday, 31 December)

Justin Chen-Wells

• standards must not be subject to patents (Tuesday, 31 December)

Kendall Helmstetter Gelner

• [www-patentpolicy-comment] <none> (Monday, 30 December)

Kevin Caswick

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting. (Tuesday, 31 December)

Kevin D. McAllister

• No 'field of use' patent restrictions (Monday, 30 December)

Lance Heller

• I fully support the FSF position on the proposed "Royalty-Free" Patent Policy (Monday, 30 December)

Liam Morland

• Royalty-Free Patent Policy and the GPL (Tuesday, 31 December)

Lincoln Bertram

• My opinion counts... (Monday, 30 December)

Lourens Steenkamp

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting. (Wednesday, 1 January)

Lukasz M. Pogoda

• On W3 Consortium "Royalty-Free" Patent Policy (Sunday, 29 December)

Mads Sejersen

• Feedback (Tuesday, 31 December)

Mark Janssen

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting. (Thursday, 9 January)

Mark P Sullivan

• Comments on W3C Patents Policy (Monday, 30 December)

markem

• Section 3 of the W3C's proposed patent policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Michael Labhard

• Amend Consortium Patent Policy "RF" patent Provision (Tuesday, 31 December)

Michael Poole

• Draft policy, good; software patenting, bad (Tuesday, 31 December)

Michael S. Keller

• Royalty-free W3C policies (Tuesday, 31 December)

Michael Spahn

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting. (Friday, 17 January)

Michael Upchurch

• Disapprove of software patents, PERIOD. (Tuesday, 31 December)

Middleton, Michael

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting. (Tuesday, 31 December)

Mike S

• Call for Comments: W3C Royalty-Free Patent Policy Last Call Working Draft (Tuesday, 31 December)

Mike Strean

• Comment on W3C Royalty-Free Patent Policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

MJ Ray

• Please drop the "Field of Use" clause. (Tuesday, 31 December)

Myron

• Last Call comment on the patent policy of the W3C (Tuesday, 31 December)

Nick Phillips

• Worried about possible non-approval of draft policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Nickolai Dobrynin

• [www-patentpolicy-comment] <none> (Wednesday, 1 January)

Ondrej Jombik

• Your patent policy problem with free software (Sunday, 5 January)

paul

• Life (Tuesday, 31 December)

Paul C. Bryan

• Draft Patent Policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Paul Lewis

• Proposed Patient Policy (Section 3 ) / GPL (Section 7) (Tuesday, 31 December)

Pete Ryland

• Re: MS views on Last Call Patent Policy Draft (Friday, 24 January)

Peter Abramowicz

• 'Field of Use' restriction (Tuesday, 31 December)

Peter Berenyi

• Some more background info on MS' views (Wednesday, 22 January)
• Standardization process à la Microsoft (Wednesday, 22 January)

Pierre Machard

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting (Tuesday, 31 December)

Pontus Johannisson

• No software patents! (Monday, 13 January)

proclus@gnu-darwin.org

• Section 3 of proposed patent policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Ralph Clark

• Patent Policy working draft: RF licensing requirements (Wednesday, 1 January)

Rikard Anglerud

• Draft policy approval (Tuesday, 31 December)

rob@printf.org

• Comment (Monday, 30 December)

robert mudry

• Acacia Research software patent claim for streaming media (Saturday, 25 January)

Ron@Dotson.net

• NO on "Royalty-Free Patent Policy" (Monday, 30 December)

Seth Johnson

• SBC Pursuing "RAND" Patent on Website Navigation (Monday, 20 January)
• Standards are . . . (Sunday, 5 January)
• Another Comment That Failed to Get Posted (Wednesday, 1 January)
• Patent Policy Comments That Failed to Get Posted (Wednesday, 1 January)

Slim

• W3C's proposed patent policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Sonam Chauhan

• DISAPPROVE of draft policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

soso@busymonkey.org

• Regarding Royalty-Free Patent Policy, sec. 3, item 3 (Monday, 30 December)

Stanley A. Klein

• Comment on Clause 3 of Section 3 of draft policy (Monday, 30 December)

stephan wehner

• www patentpolicy comment (Monday, 30 December)

Stephen Scherer

• Comments on W3C Royalty-Free Patent Policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Steve Langasek

• I grudgingly approve of the draft policy (Wednesday, 1 January)

Steve Murphy

• Royalty-Free Patent Policy Feedback (Tuesday, 7 January)

Susan Lesch

• Summary of 13 January 2003 Patent Policy Working Group Teleconference (Saturday, 25 January)
• Summary of 6 January 2003 Patent Policy Working Group Teleconference (Tuesday, 14 January)
• Summary of 16 December 2002 Patent Policy Working Group Teleconference (Tuesday, 7 January)

Syd Bauman

• field of use restrictions must go (Tuesday, 31 December)

Ted Guild

• Re: archive system bug (Thursday, 2 January)

Terra Info

• Comment (Tuesday, 31 December)

venugopalm@vmoksha.com

• Royalty-Free Patent Policy: Request for Change in Section 3, Item 3 (Tuesday, 31 December)

vsedach@ucalgary.ca

• Patent policy call for comments. (Tuesday, 31 December)

w3ccomment@nickwillson.com

• Patent policy draft (Tuesday, 31 December)

Wallwork, Nathan

• comment on W3C Royalty-Free Patent Policy (Tuesday, 31 December)

Ward Vandewege

• Last call working draft comments (Tuesday, 31 December)

Winston Neutel

• In favour of draft policy - against software patenting (Tuesday, 31 December)

Zack Johnson

• Royalty-Free Patent Policy GPL Encumbrance = Bad News (Tuesday, 31 December)

Éric Depagne

• Approve of draft policy - disapprove of software patenting. (Monday, 6 January)

Last message date: Thursday, 30 January 2003 14:01:58 UTC