Re: wsa:Action in responses

* Conor P. Cahill <concahill@aol.com> [2005-03-11 10:22-0500]
>    I am not comfortable with the current model for the [action] property on
>    response messages that requires that the [action] be specfied and the
>    WSDL binding requires that this be set to the WSDL output binding for
>    the input request.
> 
>    I believe that the [action] element should be associated with the
>    receiving party and not the sending party.  In the case of a response,
>    the receiving party is the client (who's WSDL is *not* specifed on the
>    host side).

Actually, I see [action] associated with a message, not any particular
sending or receiving node: as the spec describes it, it is "an
identifier that uniquely (and opaquely) identifies the semantics
implied by this message."

So I don't see any problem here.

Cheers,

Hugo

-- 
Hugo Haas - W3C
mailto:hugo@w3.org - http://www.w3.org/People/Hugo/