- From: Dr. Olaf Hoffmann <Dr.O.Hoffmann@gmx.de>
- Date: Fri, 5 Oct 2007 15:37:41 +0200
- To: public-html@w3.org
What I missed so many years in (X)HTML is some useful markup for poems. The result we can see in the 'real web life' - a lot of meaningless tag soup around, disoriented authors lost between silence and semantically meaningless markup... Obviously poem markup is still not available in 'HTML 5'. Why not? Can this be added to the 'HTML 5' draft? It is pretty nice to have something like 'section, 'article', 'header' in 'HTML 5' (why not a generic heading element as h from XHTML2 by the way? This would be pretty useful for poems as well as for larger projects as anthologies, books or general content fragments joint together for example with server sided scripts as PHP). Some useful and usable markup for poetry is still missing. If someone really tries to markup a poem today, one ends up with a div-class-tag-soup-nonsense. And there are many authors out there publishing poetry only in the web, currently without having any sufficient markup elements in (X)HTML for this. According to my observation readers of poetry and general literature have a wide range of capabilities (a lot of readers of poetry are robots from search engine for example ;o) Therefore it is quite useful to markup those type of literature to make elements with a semantic meaning accessible for authors in (X)HTML and to simplify the identification of poetry for readers. I think, it is the main purpose of a 'Text Markup Language' as (X)HTML to markup text in a semantic way, isn't it? Poems are text - lets markup it now ;o) Some useful elements (block elements): 'poem' - container for a poem, similar to a section, may contain header, footer, div, p (maybe useful for modern poetry), strophe, line, h 'strophe' - stanza or strophe of a classical poem, may contain either line or (inline elements or CDATA) 'line' - a line or row of a poem, may contain inline elements or CDATA 'h' - a heading of a poem I think such a construction covers already many types of poems. For non-classical as for example concrete poetry this is maybe sufficient too, still div or p can be used to realize non-conventional content.
Received on Friday, 5 October 2007 13:49:30 UTC