Re: Level of specification detail (Was Re: Proposal to Adopt HTML5)

Dylan Smith wrote:
> The tag soup out there today was cooked up by authors. The guys in the cube
> farms whipping out sites need just as much precision as implementors.
> Perhaps not the same level of detailed reasoning, but I wholeheartedly
> concur with: 
>> there is a strong need for authors to have some kind of official and
>> complete guide/reference
> Absent some clear guidelines on how to actually use a new spec, it'll be
> just as abused as the current model.

I'm sympathetic to that position, but there's little value in us
debating whether the need is there or not; the question is
whether there's sufficient effort available in this Working Group
to produce and review materials that are aimed for authors.

If someone has some material started, a pointer would be great.
That way we can consider the alternatives concretely.

Dan Connolly, W3C

Received on Friday, 13 April 2007 02:47:05 UTC