- From: Toby Haynes <thaynes@sympatico.ca>
- Date: Sun, 30 Sep 2001 13:40:20 -0400
- To: www-patentpolicy-comment@w3.org
These comments represent my own opinions and not necessarily those of IBM Canada Ltd I am deeply concerned that the W3C is considering abandoning the principles that have allowed the WWW to expand and thrive. Proposing to add RAND licensing to the W3C standards will raise the barrier of entry into the Web, squeezing out the smaller developers and limiting the possibilities of innovation in the WWW. While I can see the short-term financial gain to be had by major commercial players in the WWW by requiring fees to be paid or RAND patents to be exchanged between major players, I believe this will lead to a balkanization of the web as we know it today, leaving everyone outside the major commercial interests either staying at previous Royalty-Free architectures or, as I believe is more likely, developing a new 'forked' specification to avoid the patents and license fees that the W3C will include if this proposal is accepted. This forked standard is in nobody's interests in the long term - the most likely 'victims' of such a split will be the end users on whom the W3C members depend for their incomes, who will be faced with an increasingly loose minefield of competing standards as the Web fragments. The World Wide Web, as initiated by Tim Berners-Lee's vision, has been a success because its ideas and technologies have been freely available to all. Independent developers, both in Open Source software and in small, innovative companies have greatly enhanced the availablity and access to the WWW in ways that would never have occurred with a commercially-burdened standard. This has been to the advantage of all concerned, from the smallest backroom developer to the largest behemoth software companies, and to degrade that vision now with RAND licensing is a short-sighted, poorly thought out and eventually financially and technologically disasterous idea. Yours sincerely, Dr. Toby J.W. Haynes PhD MA Staff Software Developer for IBM Canada Ltd.
Received on Sunday, 30 September 2001 13:46:25 UTC