- From: a <a@trwnh.com>
- Date: Sat, 15 Jul 2023 20:50:27 -0500
- To: Ben Savage <btsavage@meta.com>
- Cc: Johannes Ernst <johannes.ernst@gmail.com>, public-swicg@w3.org, Ryan Barrett <public@ryanb.org>
- Message-ID: <CACG-3GgTeoyB_NFUBks44p-u301MUwFv7YjGweeQv0ZOy+YhNg@mail.gmail.com>
> Mastodon doesn’t support quote posts (yet, it’s coming), so we’d like to discuss how to model those when we send them outbound I can't guarantee anything right now, but there is currently the idea that they should be a special type of reply, for the following reasons: - Semantically, they are almost always a response to the post being quoted. - Making them replies allows for them to piggyback off of reply controls. - The fallback of being shown as a normal reply is better than the fallback of not being shown at all, or being shown as a disconnected post entirely.¹ So less of a "quote boost" / "boost with comment" and more of a "quote reply" / "reply with context preview"². Mastodon could then change its feed filtering to insert such posts into home feeds, even if you don't follow the person being quoted. Other software like Pleroma already shows all replies in timelines, regardless of whether you follow the person being replied to. (Akkoma makes it an option.) ¹ Side note about FEP-e232: FEP-e232 still allows for the "RE: url" microsyntax to be associated with an activitypub object, just like the "@mention" microsyntax gets associated with a Mention or the "#hashtag" microsyntax gets associated with a Hashtag. These are all signalled via the `name` property. Additionally, the various `rel` "quote" link relations signal that it should be treated as a Misskey/Fedibird "quote". The exact definition and semantics of a "misskey quote" depends on the Misskey project. ² The word "quote" or "quote post" needs to be defined strictly in terms of functionality, and more than one definition is possible. In a generic sense, you may be using one or several "quotes" in a forum sense, where some fragment is cited within your body content. This is altogether different than a "quote" being a preview of someone else's post above or below your post. The former actually could be better suited to being handled by FEP-e232, as that FEP deals with the content of your post rather than something external to your post.
Received on Sunday, 16 July 2023 01:50:46 UTC