W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > public-mbui@w3.org > October 2012

Re: Questions regarding the AUI diagram

From: Sebastian Feuerstack <Sebastian@Feuerstack.org>
Date: Wed, 24 Oct 2012 09:16:59 -0200
Message-ID: <5087CE2B.5090105@Feuerstack.org>
To: public-mbui@w3.org
Dear Heiko,

yes, it would be great to offer some kind of a big picture to ease people
understanding how the models fit together. I think this should be part of
the introduction document.

The idea of my submission [1] was indeed to depict the relations between
the models. Even if all models can be seen independently (GR1:Completeness)
in practice it would be hard to design an AUI without even thinking
about the
actual domain (model).

I absolutely agree with Jean, that the domain model is separate and
independent - often it already exists (at least partially) even before an
interface is designed. Thus, my proposal was to factor out of  the "id"
attribute of the
AUI model to an "entity" that every other model element from every model
is related to
(e.g. by inheritance or association)  and that is used to define mappings
(and/or transformations) between elements of models.

In my opinion, documentation, the domain model, the localization, and even
the behaviour are not part of the AUI model (because these concepts are
relevant for
other models as well) but could be connected in an elegant way by using
mappings.

Pls. note that [1] was a submission of my personal understanding of the
AUI to illustrate my idea
and is neither complete nor a shared view between the group participants.

[1] https://docs.google.com/open?id=0B5wKTP0MHyexT0JsTHpOdHpJMzA

Regards,
Sebastian

On 10/24/2012 08:04 AM, Heiko Braun wrote:
> Thanks for the clarification Jean. 
>
> I think it will help if we do properly outline the relation to models that are needed to see the "big picture", but that don't belong to the AUI layer itself. Looking at the current AUI diagram, it seems that the domain model is a part of it. 
>
> Are there any other related models that have been suppressed (i.e "mapping model")?
>
> IMO it would really helpful  describe all models from a high level view, which layer they belong to and how they enrich the AUI model itself. Looking at it with my "novice" hat on, seems to be the most confusing part when getting started with the MBUI specification drafts. 
>
> Regards, Heiko


-- 
Sebastian Feuerstack
Department of Computer Science 
Federal University of Sao Carlos - Brazil 
http://www.feuerstack.org 

Check out MINT 2010 - the Multimodal INTeraction Framework 
http://www.multi-access.de 
Received on Wednesday, 24 October 2012 11:17:24 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Friday, 17 January 2020 16:24:17 UTC