Update Regarding Review of W3C Papers

Hi all,

Based on the discussion so far, here are a couple updates on the position
paper reviews:

* We are asking all Program Committee members to rate the papers and
expressions of interest on suitability of the topic to be one of the
planned lightning talks and other presentations or focus areas for the
event.
* Please use this form to rate the papers:
http://goo.gl/forms/5SJwDSQ7f9ghwW7t1
* We have decided to extend the deadline for review of the papers until end
of Monday, June 13th.

Thanks,
 - Dazza


   ________________________
   |   Daniel "Dazza" Greenwood <http://dazzagreenwood.com/>
   |   CIVICS.com <http://civics.com/> & Law.MIT.edu <http://law.mit.edu/>
   |   dazza@CIVICS.com & 617.500.3644
   |   Box 425845, Cambridge, MA 02142



On Thu, Jun 9, 2016 at 12:48 PM, Neha Narula <narula@gmail.com> wrote:

> Hi all,
>
> It's time to start reviewing.  We are doing this in a fairly informal,
> public way.  The list of position statements and expressions of interest,
> with links, is here:
>
>
> https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1n6_TKB3idRR1SJnRA43Euce_P8blPezA3FL7nDxpx8I/edit?usp=sharing
>
> We have more requests to attend than we have space, so we need to
> thoughtfully consider who to invite to attend.  Here are the criteria we
> are using:
>
>
> https://github.com/w3c/blockchain/blob/master/position-papers.md#review-criteria
>
> *Please rate as many as you are able to reasonably read and review, with
> the aim of spreading out reviews to cover all of the submissions. *
>
> You can rank each submission on a scale of 1-5, where 1=strong reject,
> 2=weak reject, 3=neutral, 4=weak accept, and 5=strong accept.  Enter your
> numerical score in the appropriate cell of the spreadsheet, and if you have
> review comments, enter those as a comment on the cell.
>
> We will average the reviews and sort them, taking as many as we can going
> down the list, depending on capacity.
>
> Please prioritize the non-PC submissions.  I have separated out the PC
> submissions at the bottom.
>
> Everyone is using the same spreadsheet; mistakes are inevitable, but
> Command(Control)-Z is your friend (Edit->Undo).  That's the beauty of
> operational transforms!
>
> *Please get this done by EOD Sunday *so that we can send out invitations
> on Monday.  It is already very late in the game to send out invites.
>
> If you are totally Google-averse and don't have an account send me an
> email and we'll work something out.
>
> Note:  If you have not contributed thus far, not submitted anything, and
> don't do any reviews, I might move to kick you off the PC :)
>
> --
> http://nehanaru.la | @neha
>