Re: Common Sense! Was: Re: The 'resource' identified by a namespace name URI should be the namespace

Al Gilman scripsit:

> On the other hand, there is an appropriate short circuit in the case where
> the binding is be definitive [as with XSLT], i.e. the document may create
> and definitively describe just one namespace, in which case a reference to
> the document is suitable as an identifier for the namespace.  In this case
> the document itself defines a 1:1 relationship between namespace and
> document and in identifying the namespace a reference to the document is
> definitive.  The document has a unique proper namespace and the
> identification is clear.

I agree that the relationship is one-one (and even onto), but I deny
that it amounts to identity.  Confounding the namespace with the document
that describes it is a map-territory error.

-- 
John Cowan                                   cowan@ccil.org
	Yes, I know the message date is bogus.  I can't help it.
		--me, on far too many occasions

Received on Sunday, 4 June 2000 13:21:14 UTC