RE: text/xml for SOAP is incorrect

I think the problem is that XML is really not a format at all it is a
meta format.  Also something like application/xml doesn't fit since xml
isn't an application or a file format format for an application that say
application/mathematica is.  I think that xml should be its own type and
the various instances should be its subtypes.  For example

xml/mathml
xml/svgml
xml/soap
xml/wsdl
...

If xhtml could become the standard I think 

xml/xhtml

would make more sense than what we have now.  This allows a fall back to
xml for processing processors that don't have a renderer for say svgml.
I think if you compare with existing content types say image/jpeg you'll
see that as a metaphor xml has more in common with image than with jpeg.

Matthew Jones
mjones@netsilicon.com

 

Received on Wednesday, 19 September 2001 10:44:13 UTC