Re: body-tag with non-existing attributes error in HTML5 validation

On Mar 23, 2009, at 00:09, olivier Thereaux wrote:

> Hi Tobias,
> On 22-Mar-09, at 6:44 AM, Tobias Stamm wrote:
>> I'd like to report a possible bug in the experimental HTML5- 
>> checker: Very often I get the following error since I moved to HTML  
>> 5:
>> Line 15, Column 5: Attribute name not allowed on element body at  
>> this point..
>> <body>
>> Element-specific attributes for element body:None.
>> ---
>> You don't need to explain the meaning of this error message, that's  
>> perfectly clear (although there is nothing to complain about in my  
>> code: no attributes within my body tag).
> I've seen this happen a few times, strangely indeed: the html5  
> engine will complain about markup that isn't there. Very puzzling.  
> Generally, restarting the html5 engine does the trick. I did that  
> just now: can you check whether the issue still happens?
> Henri, is this an issue you have encountered in the past? If not,  
> maybe the stack trace on could help understand the  
> problem.

Yes, this is a known and fixed issue. The basic problem is that  
isindex handling caused attributes to be added to an object that was  
supposed to be a no-attribute singleton object.

This has been fixed in svn and on

Henri Sivonen

Received on Monday, 23 March 2009 07:31:23 UTC