- From: Lofton Henderson <lofton@rockynet.com>
- Date: Tue, 12 Nov 2002 12:04:59 -0700
- To: John.Robert.Gardner@Sun.COM
- Cc: www-qa-wg@w3.org
Hi JR, Thanks for the feedback... At 01:39 PM 11/12/02 -0500, Johnrobert Gardner wrote: >[...] >I'm filling in for Jack until we can scope our partic from our >QA-chartered internal org's. I'm trying to get up to speed here on the >reading, so please bear with me as my role popped up hear a little >unexpectedly. > >Re. below, however, I wanted to weigh in and suggest that I hope it was >only the latter contingency Lofton makes, that use cases were >"unitentional casualties" and, by implication, will be returned to the >requirements. It is very important these are retained ... To update you and the rest of the QAWG... I had a bit of off-list discussion with the other editors, and we agreed it was an "unintentional casualty". There will probably be a suggested correction circulated sometime in the next couple of weeks. -Lofton. >Lofton Henderson wrote: > > > > QAWG -- > > > > It appears that we may have inadvertently dropped some explicit conformance > > requirements in the new (20021108) SpecGL version [1]. Referring to the > > 20020826 version, for example checkpoint 3.1 ([2]) said: > > > > "[...]the specification must explain why profiles are necessary, by > > reference to use cases and/or project requirements." > > > > Such a requirement was repeated for several other of the DoV (for modules > > and levels, at least). > > > > Did we discuss dropping these requirements? (If yes, can someone point to > > the decision?) > > > > Or, was this an unintentional casualty of SpecGL reorganization? (In > > CK13.4 there is allusion in the 3rd bullet to the requirement to be able to > > navigate to some statements, but we don't actually have requirements for > > the statements anywhere else -- in this sense, the 3rd bullet is different > > from all the others). > > > > -Lofton. > > > > [1] http://www.w3.org/TR/2002/WD-qaframe-spec-20021108/ > > [2] > > > http://www.w3.org/TR/2002/WD-qaframe-spec-20020826/#Ck-choose-profile-grouping > >-- >=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-| >John Robert Gardner | >Business Management | >Technology Office, IT | >Sun Microsystems Inc., UBUR02-306 | >1 Network Drive | >Burlington, MA 01803-0903 | >Ph. 781-730-4012/#6-9482 fax 442-1539 | >e-mail john.robert.gardner@sun.com | >----------------------------------------| >Calendar: http://cal.central.sun.com/?calid=jg113402&security=1 >http://vedavid.org/diss/ >OPINIONS AND VIEWS NOT NECESSARILY THOSE OF SUN MICROSYSTEMS, ET AL
Received on Tuesday, 12 November 2002 14:04:25 UTC