- From: Jonathan Borden <jborden@mediaone.net>
- Date: Tue, 2 Oct 2001 09:44:20 -0400
- To: <www-patentpolicy-comment@w3.org>, <xml-dev@lists.xml.org>
The new W3C IPR/patent policy proposal effectively writes in stone a transformation that has already occured in the W3C. The division of WG into either "royalty free" or the so-called "RAND" creates two distinct types of W3C activities, those that attempt to set standards for a wider internet/WWW, and those that have purely commercial purpose. A fractured W3C is an ineffective W3C. My question is why the W3C would consider the RAND activity? Such activities are dramatically different from the traditional spirit of the WWW and Internet which until relatively recently has been funded by government and research organizations. The "home" of the W3C at MIT emphasizes this, and the spirit of cooperation between academia and commercial interests. One cannot effectively create universal internet standards without providing these free of IPR encumbrances. By providing IPR encumbered specifications, the W3C severely dilites its mission in promoting a truly World Wide web. One must have a very strict policy regarding patents: 1) An entity _must_ disclose its applicable IPR up front. The policy _should_ state that it is the responsability of the member organization to inform its WG members of any relevent IPR and that all IPR _must_ be disclosed at the beginning of an activity. An IPR originating from the activity should be held by the W3C and released in a royalty free, IPR unencumbered fashion. 2) Commercial entities that do not wish to, or are not able, to fully disclose their IPR should be prevented access to the relevent WG activities and internal discussions if such discussions are not otherwise publically available. The W3C, in order to remain relevent, must take a leadership role in such efforts. Jonathan Borden, M.D. Assistant Professor of Neurosurgery Tufts University School of Medicine Chair, ASTM E31.25 XML Healthcare Schemas speaking for myself
Received on Tuesday, 2 October 2001 09:37:17 UTC