RE: WS-Eventing issue 6424 proposal

Gil,
 
The text (v7 of issue 6424): "The REQUIRED [event source] property
provides the value of the WS-Addressing wsa:To element." 
 
It says: in that xml skeleton, the value of "wsa:To" element is from the
[event source] property. That is it and nothing more. How "wsa:To"
should behave and used is defined in WS-Addressing . Since no change is
made to it, we avoid to re-define it here in WS-E. This is the idea
behind the update from v6 to v7. There is no override that definition
from WS-Addressing.
 
Thanks,
 
- Wu Chou.

________________________________

From: Gilbert Pilz [mailto:gilbert.pilz@oracle.com] 
Sent: Monday, March 09, 2009 4:04 PM
To: Chou, Wu (Wu)
Cc: public-ws-resource-access@w3.org; Geoff Bullen; Doug Davis
Subject: Re: WS-Eventing issue 6424 proposal


Wu,

What does being dependent on WS-Addressing have to do with requiring the
wsa:To header? WS-Addressing defines this header as optional. Why is it
necessary to override that definition?

- gp

Chou, Wu (Wu) wrote: 

	Gil, 
	 
	The sample Subscribe Section is to create a template for
Infoset. It is against the current working draft which is based on
Addressing.  Geoff makes a good point. If in the future that WS-RA
decides to loosen the dependency on WS-Addressing, we can just draft a
replacement and do a global change. In this way, we can get things
moving while keeping other things as separate issues.
	 
	Thanks,
	 
	- Wu Chou.