- From: William Henry <william.henry@iona.com>
- Date: Wed, 17 Jan 2007 16:48:18 -0700
- To: public-ws-policy@w3.org
- Message-Id: <94DA2C07-FCF1-4489-9AF7-D87D0953AB1F@iona.com>
Title: Basic Concepts section to Policy in primer does not explain attachment Description: Section 2.2. is basically an introduction to to why someone might use policy and explains this from the point of view of a simple SOAP message that wants to use WS-Addressing. The section then shows a simple policy to cover this case. However the example just mentions that the policy can be attached to the WSDL binding. It doesn't show how this is done. Surely this is fundamental for a new user of Policy. I think that this first example should demonstrate how the policy might be simply attached to a binding in a WSDL. Justification: For a new user of WS-Policy thePrimer should be explaining why you might use policy (this section does that), and how you would use a policy - two parts a) how to express it (section does that) and b) how to use the expression (section just mentions this but does not show an example - a simple one would suffice). Proposal: Change this section to add an example that shows the policy defined in the example attached to a binding in the WSDL. <wsdl:binding name="AddressingBinding" type="tns:RealTimeDataInterface" > <Policy> <wsap:UsingAddressing /> </Policy> <wsdl:operation name="GetRealQuote">…</wsdl:operation> … </wsdl:binding> Notice that this example does not use any references but shows the most basic way of attaching to a binding. The section can then point to the section on How to attach Policy to WSDL. Note: Referencing the attachment section will not suffice as the attachment section only shows how to attach using a reference. (separate issue to be raised)
Received on Wednesday, 17 January 2007 23:48:37 UTC