Re: Request IG Charter update

Dear Narm,
I agree with your proposal.  This was actually one of the point that Opera  
raised during the workshop

(see our statement for example

As for other topics, we don't need to define "how to do it" in the charter,
so a generic reference to the topic will be sufficient imo.

Charles, since you are more familiar with W3C terminology/procedure could  
you try to formulate it in a proper way and include it into the charter  
(among the "The tasks the Interest Group will undertake include") for  

Another question: Are there still pending comments or we can consider the  
draft ready for (first) AC review?


On Tue, 12 Oct 2010 09:30:50 +0200, Gadiraju, Narm <> wrote:

> I propose that Compliance and Interoperability (C&I) be added to the  
> scope.  Although PC browsers gracefully handle the interoperability  
> issues that arise from optional features and/or ambiguities in the  
> specification; CE devices (and content providers) depend on C&I for  
> predictable and seamless user experience.  Also, if C&I is in scope,  
> then other SIGs that have strict certification programs will be more  
> inclined to reference W3C specifications, rather than invent their own.
> - narm
> narm gadiraju
> | W: 503-712-8599 | M: 503-705-0573
> -----Original Message-----
> From:  
> [] On Behalf Of ???
> Sent: Monday, October 11, 2010 8:53 PM
> To:
> Cc: 'Kazuyuki Ashimura'; 'FUNAHASHI Yosuke'
> Subject: Request IG Charter update
> Dear Ashimura san and Yosuke san,
> Would you please update IG draft charter for reflecting the discussion  
> so far? Adding priority and use case wording in scope? If possible,  
> mentioning some major example like HTTP adaptive streaming for VOD, TV  
> API for interaction with other device, profiling of HTML spec for TV  
> would be helpful to get an hint of this work.
> Ashimura san, can I ask a favor again about the schedule for IG  
> formation?
> Thanks for your support.
> HJ

Giuseppe Pascale
Linux Devices SDK
Opera Software - Sweden

Received on Wednesday, 13 October 2010 12:32:01 UTC