Re: Issue-170

Hi Ninja,

As I understand Mike's amendment it would preclude the practice known "data append", i.e.,  combing data from outside the context  of the request with data obtained by the first party in the context of the request.  If I'm understanding the proposal correctly, I'm comfortable with Mike's amendment.


On Jun 3, 2014, at 8:41 AM, Ninja Marnau <> wrote:

> Hi John,
> Mike amended your proposal on first party restrictions.
> Could you take a look at the wiki whether Mike's text proposal does reflect what you had in mind?
> Thanks,
> Ninja
> Am 30.05.14 15:10, schrieb Mike O'Neill:
>> Hash: SHA1
>> Here is my text for Issue-170.
>> I have (hopefully friendly) amended  John Simpsons Proposal by referencing our definition of Tracking and taking out the restriction in later data use as 3rd Party, as this is covered by Walter’s Proposal for Issue-219 (which I support). I have also incorporated the gist of Rigo’s Proposal about the use of DNT:0 as an e-privacy consent mechanism, and the bit in Vinay’s proposal about service providers.
>> Proposal:
>> If a 1st Party receives a request with DNT:1 set then data regarding or identifying the user initiating the request MUST NOT be shared between Parties outside the context of the request, other than between the 1st Party and its service providers or for permitted uses as defined within this recommendation. A 1st Party MAY elect further restrictions on the collection or use of such data.
>> If, as a result of an explicitly-granted exception, a 1st Party receives a request with DNT:0 set then data regarding the user MAY be used or shared but only for the purposes that were clearly and comprehensively explained when the exception was granted.
>> Version: GnuPG v1.4.13 (MingW32)
>> Comment: Using gpg4o v3.3.26.5094 -
>> Charset: utf-8
>> Mhg07ZnsPgjyaLJO/gXrjO+V42K9sv2E3cteLz8aGqCNkxT2x+XXt9oXF+zA17gl
>> WCfIfrGQ6SE1Z6TJrAItgDYPhp19cnARRn1skQqd3xaZ/GPn3W7ayaMWc8wxm805
>> tth/kRaiCf+i73zrE8LuE63Y83M1MHqgAzolsAS0eeMVHKJH3FOYYd4StHQKqJeG
>> 0k3HkagAkml9JAKDejz5opVJSbOAX07VWOWqSWSwUvHf5jGo5V9vMs6c/AgLaMru
>> AIY8Vq0oWatAzVZkGUFxAjXo4OTu0P3vxo9tIlFM1PJmOHihh1fmEeYG2hc/E+o=
>> =qa25
>> -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Received on Tuesday, 3 June 2014 18:40:58 UTC