Re: the suggested initial goal [ Re: Welcome!

On 13/07/16 02:56, james anderson wrote:

[snip]

> yes, i did an initial example in the wiki, just to show what one needs to be
> able to look at in one plac just in order to comprehdne an issue.

To be honest, I have no idea what I'm looking at there - assuming we're talking 
about the same wiki page:

https://github.com/w3c/sparql-exists/wiki/Examples

I see two SPARQL queries, the first followed by something which vaguely looks 
like a template for a query solution ( a lot of "s", "p" and "o" in various 
layers of bracketing) and then the sentence "the dataset as turtle", the second 
followed by "the intended solution as csv".

Admittedly I haven't quite caught up with all the correspondence yet, but none 
of this really clarifies what the issue is, to me.

Or do I perhaps misunderstand and is this merely a *template* you provided, that 
we collectively need to fill in with _actual_ examples?

I'll be happy to assist with formatting if someone can provide some raw data:

1. a (minimal) sample dataset
2. a sample SPARQL query (we got those already)
3. expected outcome of query execution on the sample dataset

I realize point 3 is exactly where the issue/dispute/uncertainty is, but picking 
_some_ example outcome gives us a good starting point, both for implementors to 
try their engine and see how it compares, and for us all to go back to the spec 
and see how we 'algebraically' arrive at that outcome.


Kind regards,

Jeen

Received on Tuesday, 12 July 2016 21:28:48 UTC