what do we need for the CR meeting?

The page recording the status of many of the LC issues has been changed to 
have "Closed" status.  I don't agree with this change, as it removes the 
information that is part of the "Resolved" status, namely that the person who 
commented is satisfied with the changes that the WG made in response to the 
comment.

My view is that all "Resolved" issues are non-issues at the CR meeting.  
However, "Closed" means either that the commenter is satisfied or the WG 
decided to continue without ensuring that the commenter is satisfied, and thus 
will all need to be addressed, one by one, at the CR meeting.

Is this going to be the case?  If so, issues where the commenter is satsified 
should be given a special status so that they don't need to be considered.

peter

Received on Wednesday, 23 October 2013 20:49:41 UTC