Re: discussion example

Hi Paul, all.
Sorry for the late response. By clarifying the location concept, I wasn't
referring to changing the example, I meant that we have to be careful when
stating that a resource has some provenance information located somewhere,
because if we don't model it properly it can be misunderstood with the
location the resource is referring to. For example, a travel guide can refer
to Paris, but it may be created in England.

I have also added some additional provenance questions about the example.
Please feel free to modify them if you don't agree with them.

Best,
Daniel

2011/5/9 Paul Groth <pgroth@gmail.com>

> Hi Daniel,
>
> Could you send a modified version of the example text to the list?
>
> It's probably premature to talk about any existing vocabulary. I think, we
> should first just agree on the example and then after that discuss how the
> example illustrates the concepts from the charter.
>
> For the provenance questions, please go ahead and edit the wiki and let the
> list know the changes you made.
>
> thanks!
> Paul
>
>
> Daniel Garijo wrote:
>
>> Hi all,
>> from my part, I really like the example. However, I would like the
>> location concept to be further clarified.
>> The RDF data could have been produced/edited in England but refer to
>> govermental data about somewhere else.
>> We have to make sure to distinguish between this 2 kind of locations,
>> since the final user can be confused.
>>
>> As for the concept illustrations, are we going to develop one with the
>> list of provenance concepts, or are we
>> going to develop several illustrations showing how to handle the example
>> with different vocabularies (OPM, PML, etc.)?,
>> (as James suggested in the telecon).
>>
>> Best,
>> Daniel.
>>
>> PS: If we have more provenance questions, shall we edit the wiki
>> directly or open a new discussion?
>>
>> 2011/5/6 Paul Groth <pgroth@gmail.com <mailto:pgroth@gmail.com>>
>>
>>
>>    Hi All:
>>
>>    We agreed at yesterday's telecon[1] that we would adopt an
>>    example-based approach to discussing the charter concepts.
>>
>>    You can find a data journalism example here [2]. This is strongly
>>    inspired by the News Aggregator scenario from the incubator but has
>>    been simplified. If also adds an element of linked data to the mix
>>    in particular it tries to illustrate a connection to web architecture.
>>
>>    It covers all concepts listed in the charter. We added a little bit
>>    around location to begin to address the comments from Carl [3].
>>
>>    What do you think? Is this a good example to work from?
>>
>>    It would be good to get an agreement on the example by Monday next
>>    week so we can begin discussing concept illustrations before next
>>    week's telecon.
>>
>>    regards,
>>    Paul
>>
>>    [1] http://www.w3.org/2011/prov/meeting/2011-05-05#resolution_3
>>    [2] http://www.w3.org/2011/prov/wiki/ProvenanceExample
>>    [3]
>> http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-prov-wg/2011May/0006.html
>>
>>
>>