- From: Uli Sattler <sattler@cs.man.ac.uk>
- Date: Thu, 2 Oct 2008 10:45:32 +0100
- To: "Peter F. Patel-Schneider" <pfps@research.bell-labs.com>
- Cc: public-owl-wg@w3.org, Sean Bechhofer <sean.bechhofer@manchester.ac.uk>
wow, this was really helpful for me - it clarifies some questions i had related to SKOS. Am I right in assuming that, if S11 was resolved in some way to be in OWL 2 DL (e.g., by replacing rdfs:label with an object property owl:label as suggested before), then S56-S58 would also automatically fall into OWL 2 DL? On 2 Oct 2008, at 00:18, Peter F. Patel-Schneider wrote: > Here is my translation of the SKOS specification into OWL 2. I > grabbed > the 62 statements of the spec and put the OWL 2 translation after each > of them (except for the ones that aren't OWL 2). > > I've included this both in-line (for easy perusal) and as a binary > attachment (which may not get so mangled). > > peter > > > ** Not in OWL 2 DL > *** Not in OWL 2 > > S1 skos:Concept is an instance of owl:Class. > Declaration( Class(skos:Concept) ) > > S2 skos:ConceptScheme is an instance of owl:Class. > Declaration( Class(skos:ConceptScheme) ) > S3 skos:inScheme, skos:hasTopConcept and skos:topConceptOf are each > instances of owl:ObjectProperty. > Declaration( ObjectProperty(skos:inScheme) ) > Declaration( ObjectProperty(skos:hasTopConcept) ) > Declaration( ObjectProperty(skos:topConceptOf) ) > S4 The rdfs:range of skos:inScheme is the class skos:ConceptScheme. > PropertyRange(skos:inScheme skos:ConceptScheme) > S5 The rdfs:domain of skos:hasTopConcept is the class > skos:ConceptScheme. > PropertyDomain(skos:hasTopConcept skos:ConceptScheme) > S6 The rdfs:range of skos:hasTopConcept is the class skos:Concept. > PropertyRange(skos:hasTopConcept skos:Concept) > S7 skos:topConceptOf is a sub-property of skos:inScheme. > SubPropertyOf(skos:topConceptOf skos:inScheme) > S8 skos:topConceptOf is the owl:inverseOf the property > skos:hasTopConcept. > InverseProperties(skos:topConceptOf skos:hasTopConcept) > > S9 skos:ConceptScheme is disjoint with skos:Concept. > DisjointClasses(skos:ConceptScheme skos:Concept) > > S10 skos:prefLabel, skos:altLabel and skos:hiddenLabel are each > instances of owl:DatatypeProperty. > Declaration( DataProperty(skos:prefLabel) ) > Declaration( DataProperty(skos:altLabel) ) > Declaration( DataProperty(skos:hiddenLabel) ) > S11 skos:prefLabel, skos:altLabel and skos:hiddenLabel are each > subproperties of rdfs:label. > ** SubPropertyOf( skos:prefLabel rdfs:label ) > ** SubPropertyOf( skos:altLabel rdfs:label ) > ** SubPropertyOf( skos:hiddenLabel rdfs:label ) > S12 The rdfs:range of each of skos:prefLabel, skos:altLabel and > skos:hiddenLabel is the class of RDF plain literals. > PropertyRange( skos:prefLabel rdf:Text ) > PropertyRange( skos:altLabel rdf:Text ) > PropertyRange( skos:hiddenLabel rdf:Text ) > [snipp] > PropertyRange( skosxl:altLabel skosxl:Label ) > PropertyRange( skosxl:hiddenLabel skosxl:Label ) > S56 The property chain (skosxl:prefLabel, skosxl:literalForm) is a > sub-property of skos:prefLabel. > ** SubPropertyOf( PropertyChain( skosxl:prefLabel > skosxl:literalForm ) skos:prefLabel ) > S57 The property chain (skosxl:altLabel, skosxl:literalForm) is a > sub-property of skos:altLabel. > ** SubPropertyOf( PropertyChain( skosxl:altLabel > skosxl:literalForm ) skos:altLabel ) > S58 The property chain (skosxl:hiddenLabel, skosxl:literalForm) is > a sub-property of skos:hiddenLabel. > ** SubPropertyOf( PropertyChain( skosxl:hiddenLabel > skosxl:literalForm ) skos:hiddenLabel ) > > S59 skosxl:labelRelation is an instance of owl:ObjectProperty. > Declaration( ObjectProperty( skosxl:labelRelation ) ) > S60 The rdfs:domain of skosxl:labelRelation is the class > skosxl:Label. > PropertyDomain( skosxl:labelRelation skosxl:Label ) > S61 The rdfs:range of skosxl:labelRelation is the class skosxl:Label. > PropertyRange( skosxl:labelRelation skosxl:Label ) > S62 skosxl:labelRelation is an instance of owl:SymmetricProperty. > SymmetricProperty( skosxl:labelRelation ) > <SKOS-spec.text>
Received on Thursday, 2 October 2008 09:53:45 UTC