Re: telco this Friday, 15:00 (CET)


unfortunately (or fortunately) I'm leaving for my summer vacation this 
evening, and I won't be able to make the call tomorrow, I'll be reading 
mails occasionally in the following days.

As for the main point:

> 1) Strong vs. weak linking
> Guido has recommended that we do not create formal links to other 
> models, e.g. by equivalentClass or subClassOf axioms, but we use "weak" 
> and "informal" links through rdfs:comment and the like.
>  From a SW perspective, this approach is non-orthodox I think. The whole 

> SW is about formalization. Informal links can not be used by machines to 

> align datasets, do distributed querying etc. Informal links in this 
> sense are only documentation and for human inspection and reasoning. 
> This is exactly what the SW wants to avoid, i.e. that we always have to 
> appeal to intuition of people ;-)
> I do not have a very strong position on this issue, but if some of us 
> would still give a few cents for the SW idea, then we should go for a 
> more formal and thus stronger linking. Just my two cents.

There's no room to start a discussion on the SW vision here, but let me 
point out that formally linking to existing ontologies means embracing all 
the commitments of those ontologies, which would require a careful and 
reasoned examination. If we want to design our model as a plain extension 
of existing ones, a complete analysis of all available proposals should be 
taken into consideration. Maybe I'm missing something, but I don't think 
this study is available already. I would suggest to keep links to external 
resources as informative for now, we could promote them to the rank of 
formal axioms once we understand all the onto-logical implications and 
agree on them. 

Hope that helps!

Guido Vetere
Manager, Center for Advanced Studies IBM Italia
Rome                                     Trento
Via Sciangai 53                       Via Sommarive 18
00144 Roma, Italy                   38123 Povo in Trento
+39 (0)6 59662137 

Mobile: +39 3357454658
IBM Italia S.p.A.
Sede Legale: Circonvallazione Idroscalo - 20090 Segrate (MI) 
Cap. Soc. euro 347.256.998,80
C. F. e Reg. Imprese MI 01442240030 - Partita IVA 10914660153
Societą con unico azionista
Societą soggetta all?attivitą di direzione e coordinamento di 
International Business Machines Corporation

(Salvo che sia diversamente indicato sopra / Unless stated otherwise 

Received on Thursday, 18 July 2013 13:43:30 UTC