RE: action 226

Dear Joakim and all,

Sorry for the late updating about MediaRSS, Youtube and TXFeed.

I will update these table as soon as possible ;)

 

Best regards,

Wonsuk.

 

From: public-media-annotation-request@w3.org [mailto:public-media-annotation-request@w3.org] On Behalf Of Joakim Soderberg
Sent: Monday, March 29, 2010 12:57 AM
To: public-media-annotation@w3.org
Subject: action 226

 

Dear all,

As promised during last telcon I have checked the mapping table to see which formats are ready of LC publication. The result in short: only the MPEG7 and SMTPD tables have everything filled out (good work Werner)! Perhaps other formats are complete, but cannot be fully mapped for some reasons?

 

Q: What is the purpose of "How to do the mapping". 

Is it to give a description/comment about of the mapping?  Only Jean-Pierre and Werner has used it!

Do we want to keep this field in LC? If so we have to fill it out!

 

1) We have do designate a editor for XMP. Volunteer?

 

2) Each editor has to check his/her format and respond to my comment below.


In a not so distant future (after easter holidays) we have to vote on which formats to publish as LC, depending on their shape!

 

 

== Current status of format mappings:

XMP  (no editor designated):
 nothing defined

 

ID3 (joakim):
 datatype missing


iTunes (David):
 attribute mapping is incomplete
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 no datatypes defined
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

QT (David):
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 no datatypes defined

 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

Search Monkey (Tobias):
 nothing defined
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

MediaRDF (Tobias):
 have definitions for most fields, but some attributes are left out!

 

LOM (Tobias):
 have definitions for most fields, but some attributes are left out!

 

METS (Tobias):
 have definitions for most fields, but some attributes are left out!

 

EXIF (Tobias):
 have definitions for most fields, but some attributes are left out!


CL 1.1 (Joakim):
 relation (semantic mapping) missing

CL 2.0 (Joakim)

 attribute mapping is incomplete
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 no datatypes defined

MediaRDF (Chris):
 have definitions for most fields, but some attributes are left out!

 

MIX (Felix):
 attribute mapping is incomplete
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 no datatypes defined
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

FRBR (Victor):
 Only two attributes mapped!
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

MediaRSS (Wonsuk):
 no datatypes defined  
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

TXFeed (Wonsuk):
 no datatypes defined  
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

YouTube (Wonsuk):
 no datatypes defined  
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

VRA (Veronique):
 no datatypes defined  
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

IPTC (Jean-Pierre):
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

TVA (Jean-Pierre):
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

EBUCore (Jean-Pierre):
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

EBUP (Jean-Pierre):
 no datatypes defined  
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

MPEG7 (Werner + Frank):
 complete!

 

SMTPD (Werner):
 complete!

 

Best Regards

/Joakim

 

 

 

JOAKIM SÖDERBERG M.Sc, Ph.D 
Multimedia Indexing, Senior Research Engineer, Chair W3C MAWG 


Ericsson Research
Multimedia Technologies
Sweden
SMS/MMS +46761263915
www.ericsson.com 



 





This Communication is Confidential. We only send and receive email on the basis of the terms set out at www.ericsson.com/email_disclaimer