RE: New Proposal Status

Hi Badral,

Thank you for your kind words on behalf of the group.

Could we say that you are in agreement with the DS01 other than the following areas? ::
U+1820-A Medial should be an initial
U+1823-O Final 1st and 2nd should be switched (I don’t remember talking about this one. Can you elaborate a bit more?)
U+1828-N Medial 3rd should be a final
U+182C-Q Initial 2nd and 3rd should be switched
U+182C-Q Medial 3rd and 4th forms should both be finals
U+182D-G Initial 2nd and 3rd should be switched
U+182D-G Medial 3rd should be a final

Greg

>>>>>
Sent: Friday, January 8, 2016 5:16 AM
Subject: Re: New Proposal Status

Hi Greg and all, I have to say that it is not my personal words and opinion. The following is voice of 5 Mongolian linguists, 10 Bolorsoft staff (who are developing Mongolianscript), Amarjargal Lkhamsuren (who developed some mongolian fonts), Erdenechimeg Myatav (Author of TR170), Jargal Badagarov (Buryat linguist) and Jamyansuren Onolt (Great font designer/font anatomist, philologist and calligrapher). First of all, we would like to thank Greg Eck, Richard Ishida, Andrew West, Richard Wordingham, Michel Suignard, Kamal Mansour, Deborah Anderson, Almas staff and all contributors for your efforts and activities for supporting Mongolian script. A criticism without solution or proof or suggestion is blame otherwise it's gold. Thus, every point is suggested. We have checked current status of DS01 and it is absolute no-go for the following reasons: 1. The third medial form of 1820 must be second init form of 1820. (Titim=crown in middle is inconceivable.) 2. switch the third initial and Second Initial Form 182C. 3. switch the third Initial Form and second Initial Form of 182D. 4. The third medial form of 182D must be second final form of 1820. (Segul=tail in middle is inconceivable.) 5. The third medial form of 1828 must be second final form of 1828. (Segul=tail in middle is inconceivable.) 6. switch the final first and the second final form of 1823. (The final form of 1823 is only occurred in foreign words and this form is current second final form.) 7. Where is final forms of 182C? 8. How did you consider and follow suggestions of Erdenechimeg Myatav, who is pioneer of Mongolian script issues. https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-i18n-mongolian/2015JulSep/0181.html

https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-i18n-mongolian/2015JulSep/0180.html We strictly follow above rules and suggestions. Greg, please squarely consider our recommendations and suggestions. I hope that you don't treat above suggestions stepmotherly, like my previous comments and suggestions.
Cheers, Badral Sanlig and et al.
>>>>>