- From: Reinier Kaper <rp.kaper@gmail.com>
- Date: Mon, 9 Sep 2013 08:54:07 -0400
- Cc: HTMLWG WG <public-html@w3.org>
- Message-ID: <CAAz96OvhtzzhoP1qki=xepiNgs6+jgpTjG=kxRPnuc2McqGDrw@mail.gmail.com>
On 9 September 2013 06:42, Jukka K. Korpela <jukka.k.korpela@kolumbus.fi>wrote: > 2013-09-09 13:27, Leif Halvard Silli wrote: > >> There is no real-world disagreement about the fact that the the >> responsibility for whether one uses <em>, <i> or <font> is the the author >> of the current page. That is, in my view, a straw man. >> > > I don’t quite see what are referring to. > > If quoted text (no matter what, if any, markup is used to indicate it as a > quotation) is from a web page, or generally an HTML document, then it seems > natural to require that the original markup be preserved, unless there is a > technical reason that prevents it. Even if it is deprecated, obsolete, and > whatever, it’s what the author of the quoted page has chosen, so in a > quotation, it shall not be “fixed” any more than you are allowed to “fix” > factual errors or wrong opinions. > > If quoted text is from another format, such as plain text file or printed > book, then I would say that markup be used only when there is an obvious > choice in HTML, mainly <p> for paragraphs. For italic, for example, it’s > debatable whether we should use just <i>, leaving it to the recipient to > interpret it (as a reader of a printed book has to do), or whether we > should use e.g. <em> or <cite> or <var> if the author’s intent is clear. I > would say that given the semantic mess around <em> and friends, clear cases > really don’t exist. > > -- > Yucca, http://www.cs.tut.fi/~**jkorpela/ <http://www.cs.tut.fi/~jkorpela/> > > I agree with Yucca here. The quote should contain its original contents if it's from a source that allows it (e.g. HTML), otherwise 'best practice' should be used to convey the message. If in a printed source something has been made bold, then it's up to the author to decide if it's meant to be <strong> or <b>. Where <b> would be a safe default (same goes for <em> and <i>).
Received on Monday, 9 September 2013 12:54:35 UTC