W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > public-comments-wcag20@w3.org > January 2005

html techniques for WCAG 2.0

From: Clarke, Andrew <Andrew.Clarke@uk.michelin.com>
Date: 24 Jan 2005 12:49:41 +0100
Message-Id: <065F841F4E0D5001*/c=fr/admd=atlas/prmd=michelin/o=fr-mta/ou=euocc/s=Clarke-A046459/g=Andrew/@MHS>
To: public-comments-wcag20@w3.org


I'm in the process of writing our approach document to WCAG requirements and
naturally wish to use the latest 2.0 and understand that it is in draft form.

I would like to add a little to the discussion, the document....


I am concerned about section 9.4 Images and text links side by side

The descriptive paragraph in 9.4 states that
'...The preferred method to address this is to put the text and image together
in one link, and provide null alternative text on the image to eliminate
duplication of text.'
and the example given is...
An icon and text are within the same link. The icon has null alt text and the
text beside it describes the link.
<a href="products.html">
  <img src="icon.gif" alt="" />
  Products page

This however conflicts with section 9.2 which states
Where appropriate, use the title attribute of the a element to clarify links.
My 'confusion' exists in that in 9.4 having got rid of the alt text for the
image where there is an image and text link side by side, you now have no alt or
title text for either the image or the link. I feel that you should decide
whether you are going to have a title element as in 9.2 or an image element as
in 9.4. There should be a sequence of precedents where there are multiple active
My personal preference is that the hyperlink takes precedent as that is the
operable element regardless of the fact that the anchor tag encloses an image.

I've also read in issue 896 that...
Each link must contain text in only one place (title attribute, content or IMG 
alt attribute) if there are 5 or  more A (anchor) elements in the document.

Remove text from within the anchor until it appears in only one place. Anchors 
can contain text in their body content, TITLE attribute or IMG ALT text.


I feel that there should be a table or matrix of precedents of what is most
appropriate in what circumstances if for no other reason than for consistency
which has links to usability concepts.

I'm sure however, somebody has already thought of it.

Thanks in advance for any help you may give.

Kind regards

Andrew Clarke


Corporate communications department EUR/C/I/EN
Michelin Tyre Public Limited Company
Campbell Road, Stoke-on-Trent, ST4 4EY, England
Tel ext     +44(0) 1782 403049
Tel int     (7 440) 3049
Fax ext +44(0) 1782 401751
Fax int (7 440) 1751
e-mail: andrew.clarke@uk.michelin.com
web :   www.michelin.co.uk
This email is intended only for the addressee named above and the contents
should not be disclosed to any other person nor copies taken.  If you are not
the intended recipient and/or have received this message in error, disregard the
content and return to sender.  Any views or opinions presented are solely those
of the sender and do not necessarily represent those of Michelin Tyre PLC unless
otherwise specifically stated.  We do not accept legal responsibility for the
contents of this message nor responsibility for any change made to this message
after original despatch.  Nothing in this email is to be interpreted as an
agreement on behalf of Michelin Tyre PLC.  We do not accept liability for any
damage sustained as a result of any software viruses. Michelin Tyre PLC reserves
the right to monitor and record any emails addressed to any worker at Michelin
Tyre PLC and the senders of messages shall be taken to have consented to such
monitoring and recording.

            Michelin Tyre Public Limited Company
    Registered in England no.84559. Registered office Stoke-on-Trent ST4 4EY.
Received on Monday, 24 January 2005 13:37:48 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.1 : Tuesday, 6 January 2015 21:11:05 UTC