Dear PSO colleagues, Apparently the message below has just been sent to Leslie and myself. It is fo ryour information. Best regards, Azucena >Return-Path: <weinberg@mail.msen.com> >X-Sender: weinberg@mail.msen.com >Date: Thu, 09 Aug 2001 10:51:40 -0400 >To: hans@icann.org, Amadeu@nominalia.com, ken.fockler@sympatico.ca, > mkatoh@mkatoh.net, apisan@servidor.unam.mx, touton@icann.org >From: Jonathan Weinberg <weinberg@mail.msen.com> >Subject: my reconsideration request >Cc: froomkin@law.miami.edu, lynn@icann.org, > azucena.hernandez@pop3.telefonica.es, leslie@thinkingcat.com > >Hans, Amadeu, Ken, Katoh-san, Alejandro, and Louis: > > This is meant as a personal message, not as part of the official >reconsideration file; I'm speaking for myself alone. Michael Froomkin and >I filed a reconsideration request yesterday, asking that ICP-3 (Stuart >Lynn's paper on "A Unique, Authoritative Root for the DNS") be withdrawn >from the ICP series, because it announces new policies that weren't >developed through bottom-up process. A colleague let me know this morning >that the PSO is currently developing a communication paper on alternate >roots. Leslie Daigle has forwarded RFC 2826 to W3C, ETSI, and ITU; it will >be considered within ITU by ITU Study Group 2, and within ETSI by its >Technical Bodies SPAN and TIPHON. I gather that the PSO Council plans to >prepare a common position on "Protocol aspects related to the Alternative >Root issue", to be sent to the Board for consideration in Montevideo. > > This, it seems to me, is exactly how the process should work. Once the >Board receives the PSO's paper, it can refer it to the DNSO for its input; >then, after fair public comment, it will be in a position to adopt the >document (with any appropriate changes) as its own. The resulting >document, I expect, will resemble Stuart's paper in some respects and >differ in others. Everybody wins if ICP-3 is withdrawn from the ICP series >so that it can be replaced by a document that is the product of a bona fide >consensus process. > >Jon > > >Jonathan Weinberg >weinberg@msen.com > > ************************************************* Azucena Hernandez Telefonica Desarrollo de Red c/ Emilio Vargas, 4. E-28043-MADRID Tel: +34 91 5846842 Fax: +34 91 5846843 GSM: +34 609 425506 E-Mail: azucena.hernandez@telefonica.es ************************************************ =========================================================================