Draft Telecon Minutes - 19 June 2003

Don't have the attendees list yet, but here are the minutes
otherwise.  

- Mike

WEB ONTOLOGY WORKING GROUP
AGENDA/LOGISTICS
June 19, 2003

1200 US East Coast
0900 US West Coast
1700 London
0200 Tokyo (next day)

Chair: Guus Schreiber
Scribe: Michael K. Smith

1. Administration

Role Call: <TO BE FILLED IN>

Note that this was specified to be an editors meeting,
requiring at least one editor for each document.

REGRETS: McGuinness, Stanton, Gibbins, Oberst


> Next regular telecon: June 26, chair Hendler, scribe TBD
> [will include approval of minutes of June 12 and June 19 plus full
> action item review]

2. LC Comments

> Discussion of status/actions for all nonclosed LC comments
>
> See LC status overview by Connolly:
> http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/WebOnt/lc-status-report.html

------------------------------------------------------------------------
Action items in re closed threads reviewed.

13. OWL WD comments 

DONE: 12Jun ACTION: Frank 
DONE: 12Jun ACTION: Mike S

------------------------------------------------------------------------
Open Threads reviewed.

 7 Items closed.  Lines begin with CLOSED.
15 Items waiting for acknowledgement.  Lines begin with WAITING FOR ACK.
25 Actions identified.  Lines begin with ACTION or CONTINUED.

1. "sameAs" error in OWL Language Reference 31 March 2003 

Deemed adequate response. 
ACTION: Jim Hendler.  Send response.
ACTION: Jeremy Carroll.  Generate test case.

2. Restriction, DeprecatedClass in OWL Language Reference 31 March 2003 

ACTION: Guus Schreiber will craft process response.

3. unspecified domain,range in App. C of OWL Language Reference 31 March
2003 
CONTINUED: 12Jun ACTION: Mike Dean to respond.  

4. "sameIndividualAs" error in OWL Language Reference 31 March 2003 

CLOSED.

5. Nothing in App. B of OWL Language Reference 31 March 2003 

CLOSED. Moved to RDF logic.

6. Missing AllDisjoint? 

DONE: 12Jun ACTION: DanC 
12Jun minute: DanC to respond: quote rationale from resolution on 5.21

WAITING FOR ACK.

7. S&AS comments 

WAITING FOR ACK.

8. OWL S&AS comment - owl:imports 

ACTION: Jeff Heflin - waiting for approval of response to send.

9. OWL S&AS: Translation to RDF Graphs 

DONE: 12Jun ACTION: DanC.   16 June 2003.

10. OWL Reference comment - RDF Schema for OWL 

Guus S. sent propose response.  Approved 

ACTION: Guus S. to send response.

11. search feature 

CLOSED.

12. Re: privacy in OWL 

ACTION: Guus S. to propose response.
ACTION: Mike Smith. Guide to xref any Ref. change.

13. Language Ref Appendix D editorial comments 

CLOSED.

14. [cosed] Re: AnnotationProperty missing from App. C of OWL Language
Reference 31 March 2003 

CLOSED.

15. OWL comment - language subsets and complexity 

DONE: 12Jun minute: ??? to respond
Ian Horrocks sent.

WAITING FOR ACK.

16. OWL comment - blank nodes in OWL DL 

Named data ranges
Blank nodes used more than once. Jeremy Carroll B1, B2 proof in progress.
Syntactic restrictions on unnamed indiv. (Covered)

PENDING.

Jim Hendler joined call.

17. OWL S&AS Comment - owl:imports 

Proposed response sent to WG by Heflin.
ACTION: Jim Hendler to review.

18. [clodes] Re: imports error in App. B of OWL Language Reference 31 March
2003 

CLOSED.

19. Problem with PET of sections 7.1.5 and 7.1.6 of OWL test cases 

WAITING FOR ACK.
ACTION: Jim Hendler to confirm our response.

20. Semantic Web Services for Enterprise Application Integration and
e-Commerce: extended deadline - June 30 

CLOSED.

21. daml:item 

ACTION: Jim Hendler. Respond with pointer to Issue 5.5.

22. RDFCore Comments on OWL Reference 

Guus sent partial response.
WAITING FOR ACK.

ACTION: Frank van Harmelen to respond to one open element.

23. Comments from RDFCore on S+AS 

WAITING FOR ACK.

24. Another RDF Comment on the OWL Reference Doc 

DONE: 12 Jun ACTION: Sean 
WAITING FOR ACK.

25. Comments on Owl REF document 

DONE: 12Jun ACTION: Guus (sent to WG, approved by Dan)

ACTION: Guus to send.

26. inadequate reference in Owl REF 

Guus had a link to S&AS built-in datatypes that are problematic.
Now in the RDF semantics.  S&AS points to that.

ACTION: Jeremey Carroll to send RDF link to Guus, Peter, Mike S.

27. Review section 4.1 of OWL AS&S 

DONE: 12Jun ACTION: Ian. Mailed to WG for approval.
Waiting for approval.

28. Non-global Keys 

Compound keys not in response.
ACTION: Guus to find record of decision and propose Issue to be postponed. 
ACTION: Jim Hendler to add to proposed response.  

29. OWL Comment: have long CR period for OWL, or move owl:oneOf, owl: have
Value to OWL Full 

WAITING FOR ACK.

30. OWL comment - owl:OntologyProperty 

DONE: 12Jun ACTION: Guus. 
12Jun ACTION: Jeremy. CONTINUED.
12Jun minute: Jeremy to respond 
ACTION: Guus to make Ref consistent with resolution

31. Semantics and Abstract Syntax (and some general OWL Lite, CR, &
implementation) comments 

WAITING FOR ACK.

32. Language Overview Document editorial comments 

DONE: 12Jun ACTION: Frank.
12Jun minute: Frank to respond, editorial

WAITING FOR ACK. We think.

ACTION: Guus to find our response.


33. OWL and Published Subjects 

ACTION: Jim to respond.


34. Could owl:sameAs reference non-OWL resources? 

12Jun ACTION: Pat. CONTINUED.
12Jun minute: Pat to respond

ACTION: Guus to check status.

35. OWL Abstract Syntax and Semantics review comments 

WAITING FOR ACK.

36. Missing AllSame 

DONE: 12Jun ACTION: Guus.
12Jun minute: Rationale for no AllSame: linear

WAITING FOR ACK.

37. about/base and Free to implementations 

WAITING FOR ACK.

38. QA Review of owl-semantics 

Sandro sent proposed reply.

ACTION: Dan, Jim, Guus to review reply.  
ACTION: Guus to send proposed words re xrefs to all docs.
ACTION: Peter, Guus, Frank, MKS, Jeremy, Jeff. 
All editors add link from their document to ALL others.

39. Fwd: Jena comment: Syntax Checker Implementation Report] 

WAITING FOR ACK.

40. comments on OWL Last Call drafts 

WAITING FOR ACK.

Received on Thursday, 19 June 2003 16:55:13 UTC