Re: CCXML :<move event=event$> in transition for "connection.merge.failed" - ISSUE-603

Jaya,

We have addressed your comment with the following spec changes:

OLD:
A <move> attempt MUST fail under any of the following conditions:
·         The referenced event source does not exist, or does not  
belong to the session executing the <move>;
·         The referenced event source is immovable - the CCXML session  
itself and various external event I/O processors are examples of this;
·         The referenced event source is currently bridged in a way  
that prevents it from being moved (as described below) ;
·         The session to which the event source is being moved does  
not exist, or cannot accept the event source that is being moved;
A <move> attempt MAY fail for causes other than the above, which may  
or may not be platform specific
A <move> is not allowed once an event source is associated with  
another object through an implicit or explicit <join>.

NEW:
A <move> attempt MUST fail under any of the following conditions:
·         The referenced event source does not exist, or does not  
belong to the session executing the <move>;
·         The referenced event source is immovable - the CCXML session  
itself and various external event I/O processors are examples of this;
·         The referenced event source is currently bridged to another  
object through an implicit or explicit join;
·         The session to which the event source is being moved does  
not exist, or cannot accept the event source that is being moved;
·         The event attribute is used to identify the event source,  
but refers to multiple event sources (such as connection.merge.failed);
A <move> attempt MAY fail for causes other than the above, which may  
or may not be platform specific

A <move> is not allowed once an event source is associated with  
another object through an implicit or explicit <join>.

Please let us know if this addresses your concerns. If we do not hear  
back from by 7/9 we will consider this issue closed.

Thank you again for this feedback,

Best regards,

	RJ

---
RJ Auburn
CTO, Voxeo Corporation
Chair, Editor and Chair, CCXML, VBWG, W3C

On May 7, 2009, at 9:35 AM, RJ Auburn wrote:

> Jaya,
>
> Thanks for sending this in. We are tracking this as issue id  
> ISSUE-603.
>
> Best regards,
>
> 	RJ
>
> ---
> RJ Auburn
> CTO, Voxeo Corporation
> Chair, Editor and Chair, CCXML, VBWG, W3C
>
> On May 4, 2009, at 1:27 AM, Jayalakshmi Swaminathan wrote:
>
>> Hi,
>>
>> From the CCXML specification, for event attribute of <move>:
>>
>> "The event source, from which the event object originated, if any,  
>> must be moved to the target session.
>> The event must also be sent to the target session to provide a  
>> notification."
>>
>> The attribute list for connection.merge.failed:
>> 10.6.19: connection.merge.failed
>> This event MUST be emitted when a <merge> attempt fails. This event  
>> MUST NOTchange the state of either of the Connection Objects  
>> involved in the merge operation The fields of this event are:
>> Attribute Name
>> Required
>> Type
>> Details
>> name
>> true
>> string
>> error.merge
>> connectionid1
>> true
>> string
>> The ID of the first Connection identified when the merge was invoked.
>> connectionid2
>> true
>> string
>> The ID of the second Connection identified when the merge was  
>> invoked.
>> reason
>> true
>> string
>> A description of the reason the merge failed. Content of this field  
>> is platform-specific.
>> eventid
>> true
>> string
>> The unique identifier for the event. This must match the  
>> sendidattribute of send, if the event was generated by a CCXML  
>> document.
>> eventsource
>> true
>> string
>> The unique identifier of the event source. This identifies the  
>> Platform Event I/O Processor that sent this event.
>> eventsourcetype
>> true
>> string
>> The name of the Event I/O Processor that sent this event. The value  
>> is platform dependent as this is an event generated by the Platform  
>> Event I/O processor.
>>
>> Consider the following transition:
>>
>> <transition event="connection.merge.failed">
>>    <move session_id="target_session_id" event="event$" />
>>     ...
>> </transition>
>>
>> In the above case, where we have <move> with event attribute within  
>> the transition for “connection.merge.failed”, should both event  
>> sources(connectionid1 and connectionid2) be moved to the target  
>> session??
>>
>> The specification does not talk about moving multiple event  
>> sources. All other connection events are only associated with one  
>> connection object, but this event – connection.merge.failed is  
>> associated with two connection objects. So, should both  
>> eventsources be moved to the target session? If not, what should be  
>> the handling?
>>
>> Pls clarify.
>>
>> Thanks
>> Jaya
>>
>>
>>
>>
>
>