Feedback: CCXML Last Call Working Draft Published!

Hi,

I've been coding to the new spec (released to the public today) and have
found the following problems (mostly with the DTD):

1) the specification document still refers to <eventhandler> in a number of
examples

2) The DTD specifies <eventprocesser> rather than <eventprocessor>

3) The DTD has a '#' character which seems to cause problems when using DTD
apps such as XML Spy:

  <!ELEMENT metadata (#wildCard)*> 

4) The DTD specifies that ecma script elements / <eventprocessor> / meta /
metadata are mutually exlusive, yet the spec document indicates that they
can be used side-by-side: 

  <!ELEMENT ccxml (%ecmaScriptElements; | eventprocesser | meta* |
metadata*)>

5) The DTD specifies that <startdialog> attribute 'src' is required - the
spec document says it is optional

6) The DTD declares but does not reference <createCall>.  I presume it
should be referenced in telephonyActionElements

Regards,

Alex Davis.

Technical Product Manager

Vicorp UK
Wexham Springs
Framewood Road
Wexham
Bucks
SL3 6PJ


-----Original Message-----
From: Royles, Chris 
Sent: 30 April 2004 16:30
To: Davis, Alex; Mellor, Paul
Subject: FW: CCXML Last Call Working Draft Published!




-----Original Message-----
From: RJ Auburn [mailto:rj@voxeo.com]
Sent: 30 April 2004 16:01
To: www-voice@w3.org
Subject: CCXML Last Call Working Draft Published!




The W3C Call Control Subgroup is pleased to announce that Call Control 
XML (CCXML) has reached Last Call Working Draft. The updated 
specification is available at http://www.w3.org/TR/ccxml.

  This release includes updates to the following sections:
	Session Variables Documentation
	Session Life-Cycle Details
	Element and attribute name re-factoring.
	Meta and Metadata Features
	Expanded Conferencing Events/Options
	<dialogprepare>
	Event I/O Updates (send element)
	VoiceXML Appendix

The working group is accepting comments on the specification until May 
28th so please send any feedback by then. Feedback can be submitted to 
the www-voice@w3.org mailing list.

	RJ

---
RJ Auburn
CTO, Voxeo Corporation
Chair, Call Control Sub Group, W3C
Editor, CCXML 1.0
http://www.rjauburn.com/

Received on Friday, 30 April 2004 12:29:10 UTC