Re: Terminology Question concerning Web Architecture and Linked Data

On Sat, 2007-07-07 at 14:43 +0200, Chris Bizer wrote:
> Hi all,
> Richard Cyganiak, Tom Heath and me are currently writing a tutorial on how 
> to publish Linked Data [1] on the Web and ran into some terminology 
> questions concerning Web Architecture.
> Here is the problem statement together with an example: Within the Linking 
> Open Data community project [2] different data sources (URI owners) publish 
> information about Tim Berners-Lee using different HTTP URIs:
> 1. DBpedia:
> 2. Hannover DBLP Server: 
> 3. Berlin DBLP Server: 
> 4. RDF Book Mashup: 
> The first 3 data sources follow the W3C TAG "Dereferencing HTTP URIs" 
> finding [3]

draft, in progress...

>  and redirect via HTTP 303 to documents describing Tim 
> Berners-Lee when the URIs are dereferenced over the Web. Therefore, the URIs 
> identify Tim Berners-Lee as a non-information resource.

Rather: therefore the do not claim that these URIs
identify information resources.

The lack of a claim is very different from the negation of a claim.

>  This redirect also 
> supports HTTP content negotiation and leads to HTML as well as RDF 
> descriptions of Tim.
> 5. Tim also publishes a FOAF profile in which he assigns the URI 
> to himself.
> Question 1: According to the terminology of the Architecture of the WWW 
> document [4] are all these URIs aliases for the same non-information 
> resource (our current view) or are they referring to different resources? 

They are aliases: the URI owners say so and nothing in webarch
says otherwise.

> Does the TAG finding "On Linking Alternative Representations To Enable 
> Discovery And Publishing " [5] about generic and specific resources apply 
> here, meaning that the URIs 1,2,3,5 refer to different specific 
> non-information resources that are related to one generic non-information 
> resource?

No, I don't think so.

The generic resource finding is mostly about information resources, I

> Question 2: When the URIs are dreferenced they provide quite different 
> information about Tim, which reflects the knowledge and the opinion of the 
> specific URI owner about him. Within our tutorial we need to talk about this 
> information and therefore need a term to refer to a concept that can be 
> described as "information provided by a specific URI owner about a 
> non-information resource", for example Tim. Depending on the answer to 
> question 1, what would be the correct Web Architecture term to refer to this 
> concept? Or is such a term missing?

I don't think the TAG has established a term for that.

(It sounds a bit like log:semantics from N3, but I'm not quite sure )

> Question 3: Depending on the answer to question 1, is it correct to use 
> owl:sameAs [6] to state that and 
> refer to the same thing as it is 
> done in Tim's profile.


That's sort of a circular question. It's correct because Tim says
it's correct, and he owns that name.

> Any clarifications on these question would be highly welcomed.
> Cheers
> Chris
> [1]
> [2] 
> [3]
> [4]
> [5]
> [6]
> --
> Chris Bizer
> Freie Universit├Ąt Berlin
> +49 30 838 54057
Dan Connolly, W3C

Received on Tuesday, 10 July 2007 17:08:21 UTC