- From: Shane McCarron <shane@aptest.com>
- Date: Thu, 01 Apr 2004 09:36:51 -0600
- To: www-tag@w3.org
- Message-ID: <406C3713.9050905@aptest.com>
Many of you know me as an editor of the XHTML recommendations. In addition to that work, I have been working with a separate group of people on an exciting new XML-based protocol - XCP (the XCL Control Protocol). That work has finally matured enough that we have made it public and are actively seeking input. Here is a excerpt from the web site: XCP - the XML Control Protocol - is a drop in replacement for traditional Transmission Control Protocol, or TCP. XCP has many advantages, some of which are outlined in our rationale section. With the advent of XCP/IP, connection-oriented networking will finally move from the legacy environment of inscrutable bits and bytes to a structured, human-readable world relying upon XML. XCP is the first 4th Generation Protocol, or 4GP. It is designed for a networking environment that is very fast and very reliable - the Internet of today! We understand that the TAG has examined the use of HTTP as a substrate protocol (c.f.: http://www.w3.org/2001/tag/issues.html#HTTPSubstrate-16 - "HTTPSubstrate-16: Should HTTP be used as a substrate protocol? Does W3C agree with RFC 3205?") XCP is in fact directly targeted at being such a protocol. However, it is not completely clear to us how this will dovetail with your existing "Architecture of the World Wide Web" document. We see from the document (at http://www.w3.org/TR/webarch/#xml-formats) that you envision evolution like this - and we think that our approach is consistent with your guidelines, as well as with those from the IETF's document "Guidelines for the Use of XML within IETF Protocols" (http://www.imc.org/ietf-xml-use/xml-guidelines-07.txt). However, we would like to see a deeper focus on XML-based protocols in your document - you can consider that a last call comment if you like. I guess I would appreciate it if the TAG, in its role as keepers of the internet architecture, could examine the XCP architecture at http://www.x-cp.org and think about ways that it can be enhanced to become more consistent with the W3C's view of the web. Think of this as a "last call" period for XCP - we are putting together sample implementations and getting people to deploy it now, but it is not too late to ensure we cleanly support the TAG's vision of the Internet - and vice-versa. -- Shane P. McCarron Lead Editor, W3C HTML Working Group
Received on Thursday, 1 April 2004 10:41:16 UTC