- From: fantasai <fantasai.lists@inkedblade.net>
- Date: Thu, 30 Jan 2014 02:10:02 -0800
- To: "www-style@w3.org" <www-style@w3.org>
Transitions
-----------
- Discussed status of Transitions. A bunch of issues need to move to
other specs.
- RESOLVED: Remove the paint server definition from Transitions,
deferring to the Images definition for transitioning
<image> values.
- RESOLVED: Remove the gradient animation text from Transitions.
Animations
----------
- RESOLVED: Remove bit about waiting for document load event before
starting animations
====== Full minutes below ======
Transitions
-----------
dbaron: I've made some progress on Transitions.
dbaron: A bunch of what's left is going through issues, by which I mean
"here's a 4-page email message that I think is already dealt
with, but I need to read the whole thing first".
dbaron: Probably about half the Transitions issues are value-type-specific.
dbaron: I think basically all of them should be deferred to the next
level of the spec defining those values.
dbaron: There are a few that require editing work.
dbaron: One is dealing with out-of-range values.
dbaron: I think most of what is left before LC is me doing work that
I haven't gotten to yet.
dbaron: I have not been following the Animations issues as well yet.
dbaron: Also, I've been putting in "defer til level 2" in the status
whiteboard for some issue, and have two links for the normal
and the deferred ones.
dbaron: I made some pretty significant edits around TPAC, and I think
I talked about those.
krit: One issue I'm not sure is tracked is the paint server animation.
krit: I'd remove the section completely.
RESOLVED: Remove the paint server definition from Transitions,
deferring to the Images definition for transitioning
<image> values.
dbaron: There's also a section about gradient.
dbaron: Does anyone implement the Transitions definition of gradient
interpolation, rather than Images?
krit: Blink and WK don't.
dbaron: Gecko doesn't animate gradients at all.
<leif> neither does Presto (from memory)
<florian> my memory of Presto matches Leif's
RESOLVED: Remove the gradient animation text from Transitions.
krit: I'd like to reference the shadow interpolation for drop-shadow(),
but it only defines shadow-list. Should I just say it's a list
of one item?
[some discussion]
krit: Yes.
plh: I heard you were going to move some issues to other specs.
Are you planning to do that?
dbaron: I can do it, though I'd be happy with others to help.
dbaron: I think one of the bigger Animation issues is that we agreed
to make pretty substantive changes about a year ago, which
nobody had the time to edit and I'm not sure is compatible
anymore.
dbaron: Especially regarding animating non-interpolable values.
krit: SVG's model is still a bit simpler, where it switches over at
half the time progress.
TabAtkins: We currently say that it switches at half the progress,
not half the time.
krit: Right, but that means it could hit that point more than once.
sylvaing: Last time I pull issues out of the mailing list was Jan 1st
2013 for Animations. Not sure for Transitions.
sgalineau agrees to edit CSS Animations again
<br type=coffee dur=15min>
Animations
----------
Scribe: fantasai
Scribe: fantasai
krit: Currently, animations spec states that animations start time
is easier if the document load event is firing
krit: or when property is resolved for current element
krit: whatever happens later is actually start time
krit: I don't think this is what impl do
krit: implementations start animations once style is resolved
krit: maybe we should remove sentence about document load
dbaron: I agree with the change. Thought we already had
RESOLVED: Remove bit about waiting for document load event before
starting animations
Received on Thursday, 30 January 2014 13:42:04 UTC