- From: Matthew Skala <mskala@ansuz.sooke.bc.ca>
- Date: Sat, 28 Nov 1998 16:29:53 -0500 (EST)
- To: braden@endoframe.com
- cc: "Scott K. Laws" <scott@elvis.mu.org>, style-list <www-style@w3.org>
On Sat, 28 Nov 1998, Braden N. McDaniel wrote: > This is problematic because "sentence-ending" punctuation is not unique. A > period does not necessarily mark the end of a sentence. In English at least, When do you have a period *followed by whitespace* that doesn't mark the end of a sentence? I can think of one case for that, which is the ellipsis if you spell it ". . .". I more often see people write ellipsis in ASCII files as "..." with no spaces, which would be unaffected by my suggestion. Note, too, that I'm talking about an optional feature here: people who didn't want it or didn't understand it, wouldn't turn it on. I claim that enough people want extra space between sentences that it's worth supporting them in some way, and I don't think that that algorithm I described would guess incorrectly often enough to be a problem. (I agree that asking the user agent to do a grammatical analysis is out of the question.) Authors who had unusual situations where they wanted extra inter-sentence spacing but also periods (or similar punctuation) followed by word spaces, could mark up those exceptional periods. Note, too, that word processors like Word have an option to do almost exactly what I described, forcing two spaces after every period that is followed by space at all. Lots of people use those options without appearing to suffer for it. The optional feature makes it possible for the author of a document to choose how to handle this kind of case; without it or something like it there is NO clean way to get extra space, and I don't see how CSS can be taken seriously as a format-description language when it can't describe such an ordinary format. What am I supposed to do instead? Write " " after every sentence? Just grin and bear the fact that my sentences are too close together? That hardly seems in the spirit of what CSS is supposed to be about. It sounds like you're saying that my proposal is capable of generating incorrect formatting. That's possibly true, but CSS without it or something like it is *incapable* of generating correct formatting. The third girl had an upside-down penguin on Matthew Skala her stomach, so the doctor told her, "I'll Ansuz BBS examine you for free, if you and your (250) 472-3169 boyfriend will debug my Web server." http://www.islandnet.com/~mskala/
Received on Sunday, 29 November 1998 04:06:44 UTC