- From: Neil McNaughton <neil@oilit.com>
- Date: Tue, 21 Dec 2004 11:15:29 +0100
- To: <www-rdf-interest@w3.org>
- Message-Id: <20041221101528.D102F1C001F2@mwinf0109.wanadoo.fr>
A bit of a hobbyhorse I'm afraid, but if you are getting into time sensitive resources, this is data, not text. It therefore behooves the writer of the spec to do something about metadata for the data - in particular, units of measure. I couldn't get onto the grid.ucy.ac.cy schema to see if it said anything interesting. But when I see <b> 125Mbits </b>, I am led to believe that the data is not being treated rigorously. One would have expected a value - with (perhaps) its (computing) type specified through a reference to a publicly available schema - and (definitely) its units of measure - in a similar way. Making this up with an rdf-esque pseudo code (I don't really speak the lingo.) > <rdf:Seq> > <b> <type_namespace>www.ieee.org/definitivedatatypes.xml> <data_namespace>www.iso.org/definitiveunitsofmeasure.xml> <value_type>IEE_longint</value_type> <value-uom>ISO_bps</value_uom> <value>125000000</value> And so on > </rdf:Seq> Before you look them up - the IEEE and ISO urls are fictitious - although similar may exist unbeknownst to me. The RDF community is seeking rigor for textual relationships but seems to abandon this when a data element comes along. If rdf is to be used for machine reasoning (as opposed to an alternative to local flavors of xml - or even text-described data) then it seems to me that the above is a necessary requirement. Or maybe I have misunderstood something. Neil McNaughton Editor - Oil IT Journal (www.oilit.com) _____ Subject: Re: Time-sensitive resources using RDF? > <rdf:Description> > <rdf:subject rdf:resource="http://grid.ucy.ac.cy/someCluster1" /> > <rdf:predicate > rdf:resource="http://grid.ucy.ac.cy/2003/12/GrisenSchema#bandWidth" /> > <rdf:object > > <rdf:Seq> > <b> 125Mbits </b> > <t> 200412201023 </t> > </rdf:Seq> > </rdf:object> > ...... <rdf:type rdf:resource = > "http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#statement" /> > <grisen:validFor> 2004 </grisen:validFor> > </rdf:Description> > ....
Received on Tuesday, 21 December 2004 13:34:45 UTC