- From: Andrew n marshall <amarshal@usc.edu>
- Date: Wed, 26 Nov 1997 12:14:33 -0800
- To: "'Nabil Layaida'" <layaida@sol.genie.uottawa.ca>
- Cc: "'www-multimedia@w3.org'" <www-multimedia@w3.org>
On Tuesday, November 25, 1997 7:44 AM, Nabil Layaida
[SMTP:layaida@sol.genie.uottawa.ca] wrote:
> In the SYMM group, we had very long discussions about that issue. Your
suggestion has been already discussed. Jin and I brought that problem to
the discussion table. Our proposal was to give the author the mean to group
a set of element into blocks. We proposed a comp tag which stands for
"composite". This can be even extended to typed blocks to make the
document logically structured instead of temporally or spatially.
>
> We decided for the first release of SMIL not to include this feature into
the draft. But this doesn't mean that it will not be discussed or/and
included later. Madeus which is the tool I built to author and layout
presentations supports this. So we are aware enough about this issue.
Hmmm... Adding a grouping in the form of another tag doesn't quite address
the issue. It still is limited to temporal adjacency. For example, using
standard TV and newscast models, how do you denote that two particular news
reports (probably each implemented as a <PAR> tag) are siblings in terms of
content organization when a commercial comes between them? For example:
<SEQ id='newscast'>
<PAR id='report1'> . . . </PAR>
<PAR id='report2'> . . . </PAR>
<SEQ id='sponsors'> . . . </SEQ>
<PAR id='report3'> . . . </PAR>
<PAR id='report4'> . . . </PAR>
</SEQ>
Andrew n marshall
student - artist - programmer
http://www.media-electronica.com/anm-bin/anm
"Everyone a mentor, Everyone a pupil"
Received on Wednesday, 26 November 1997 15:09:43 UTC