- From: Richard Ishida <ishida@w3.org>
- Date: Mon, 29 Jul 2013 19:12:00 +0100
- To: "Tab Atkins Jr." <jackalmage@gmail.com>
- CC: 梁海 <lianghai@gmail.com>, WWW International <www-international@w3.org>
There's a similar duplication, I noticed today, with Cambodian and Khmer. Tab, i'm cc'ing you in case you know any of the background here. RI On 29/07/2013 18:57, Tab Atkins Jr. wrote: > [-www-style, +www-international] > > Forwarding your message on to the Internationalization WG, who is > maintaining the document with those styles. > > On Mon, Jul 29, 2013 at 10:29 AM, 梁海 <lianghai@gmail.com> wrote: >> Tab Atkins and all, >> >> Of course, about the LCWD: >> >> I noticed that, besides a reasonable counter style for Bengali, `bengali`, >> there's an style identical to `bengali` but is named `eastern-nagari` and >> cataloged under "6. Devanagari". See below: >> >> 4. Bengali >> @counter-style bengali { >> system: numeric; >> symbols: '\9E6' '\9E7' '\9E8' '\9E9' '\9EA' '\9EB' '\9EC' '\9ED' '\9EE' >> '\9EF'; >> /* symbols: '০' '১' '২' '৩' '৪' '৫' '৬' '৭' '৮' '৯'; */ >> } >> >> 6. Devanagari >> … >> @counter-style eastern-nagari { >> system: numeric; >> symbols: '\9E6' '\9E7' '\9E8' '\9E9' '\9EA' '\9EB' '\9EC' '\9ED' '\9EE' >> '\9EF'; >> /* symbols: '০' '১' '২' '৩' '৪' '৫' '৬' '৭' '৮' '৯'; */ >> } >> … >> >> These two style are identical, which obviously would confuse developers. I >> was wondering why they are listed twice. >> >> And to clarify: >> 1. Eastern Nagari is not a variant or subset of Devanagari. They may be >> regarded as siblings though. >> 2. Eastern Nagari is more a historical concept (of the evolution of >> Indic/Brahmic scripts), from which Bengali script developed. Eastern Nagari >> is not a modern script. >> 3. The term Eastern Nagari may also be used as an umbrella term for its >> modern variants, which mainly consists of Bengali and Assamese script. >> Bengali and Assamese language actually employ roughly the same alphabet but >> differs in usage of some letters, which results in a unified Unicode code >> block. >> 4. It indeed may be more politically correct to say "Eastern Nagari" when >> you refer to the script of Bengali or Assamese. >> >> Please let me know if there's already discussions about this issue. I failed >> to find any in the archives. >> >> -- >> LIANG Hai(梁海) >> > > -- Richard Ishida, W3C http://rishida.net/
Received on Monday, 29 July 2013 18:12:41 UTC