W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > www-html@w3.org > May 2007

Re: Web-Forms 2.0: upload. Button apperance

From: Anatoly Kataev <w3c@dv-life.ru>
Date: Sun, 13 May 2007 20:58:53 +1100
Message-ID: <4646E15D.4000004@dv-life.ru>
To: David Woolley <forums@david-woolley.me.uk>, www-html@w3.org

David Woolley пишет:
> Anatoly Kataev wrote:
>> Styling languages? You mean CSS? I agree to style <input class=file> 
> I mean any styling language supported by the browser, of which CSS is 
> probably the most commonly used.  The www-style mailing list is not 
> restricted to the discussion of CSS, and is the appropriate mailing 
> list for this issue. 
Can you list some of them? I have slow connection and cannot dig 
through  www-style

> There is nothing in HTML that says that the text box needs to be 
> provided at all, but if it is, you have a compound of two controls, at 
> least one of which is likely to be native, which makes targeting the
> styling even more difficult.
>> impemented. Also code, which applies CSS rules to single TextEdit or 
>> Button already written in most UA's, so
>> it can be used for styling <input class=file> in case if it will be 
> I presume you meant *type*=file.
Right. My fault, i really meant type=file

> Again, you are assuming the internal structure of the element.  Again 
> you are on the wrong list.  Also note that this would have to be done 
> with pseudo-classes, if the style sheets are CSS ones.  Pseudo classes 
> are purely CSS concepts, they have no meaning in HTML.
Preudo-classes don't allow me to set caption on "Browse..." button

> input *type*=file is one of the most complex controls because it could 
> be implemented in so many different ways and because most users will 
> end up using one of the more complex native dialogues.
Can you explain that more detail?

> There is one special case, which is ex-patriot users using communal 
> PCs (libraries, where use is free in the UK, and internet cafes).  
> However, I don't think that that case applies here.  For library 
> computers, a good librarian would, given that OSes tend to be 
> multilingual these days, temporarily localise the PC for non-English 
> speakers.
Not all librarians are good :^)
> Many browsers cannot style other controls, 
IE, FF, Opera styles <input>, <teaxtarea> and <button> controls without 
any problems.

> and, in my view, styling them makes sites more difficult to use by 
> those people who are not familiar with the web and deciphering a 
> site's design metaphor.  The main use for styling, when UAs have 
> provided it, has been to allow designers to make their sites not look 
> like the standard user agent behaviour, and it is likely that a styled 
> upload control will lead to an unstyled dialogue box, breaking the 
> design by leaking the standard behaviour.
Not only designers. Many of customers don't want their sites looks like 
FreeBSD Handbook.

And also look at
It's only way to stylize INPUT i know
Do you think it's easy way? Do you think that authors of this arcticle 
have nothing to do, else as write useless articles?
Received on Sunday, 13 May 2007 09:59:53 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Thursday, 30 April 2020 16:21:03 UTC