- From: Plech¹míd Martin <Martin.Plechsmid@merlin.cz>
- Date: Mon, 28 Jan 2002 17:22:57 +0100
- To: "'www-forms@w3.org'" <www-forms@w3.org>
Hello. I have several things that I don't know how to do in XForms: 1) How to put a constraint on a set of data elements at once? The problem is in that the xforms:bind element can have the attribute "ref" only, not "nodeset". Having e.g.: <xforms:instance> <employee name="Karl" income="12345" /> <employee name="Mark" income="2345" /> <employee name="Peter" income="3458" /> <employee name="John" income="23456" /> </xforms:instance> <xforms:bind ref="employee/@income" type="xsd:int" /> this would put a constraint on Karl's @income only. 2) "readOnly" is not allowed on form controls. Thus, it seems impossible to me to have a form field displayed on several places in a form, but editable only on the place of its first occurence. I could write something like <xforms:instance> <name>Peter</name> <copy-of-name /> </xforms:instance> <xforms:bind ref="copy-of-name" readOnly="yes" /> and somehow copy the value from "name" to "copy-of-name", but this a) seems to me unnecessarily complicated (making the form control readOnly would be simpler), b) seems to me even impossible, as the standard says nothing on that readOnly data are not considered readOnly for updates by xforms actions (in fact, it is stated explicitly in section 6.1.2 that the readOnly data nodes' values cannot be changed). 3) Similarly with the "required" attribute: If a user forgets to fill in a required data field, I have to tell him which _form_control_ he has to fill in. What should I say to the user, if no form control corresponds to the required data field (the data field can be e.g. calculated)? 4) Imagine the following scenario: I want to build a form initialized with data taken from a database. These db values are read into an xforms:instance section of a xforms:model. But the form contains also other controls that are not to be initialized. As some instance data must correspond to them, there must be another xforms:instance section, distinct from the first instance. And because (a subset of) _both_ the initialized and non-initialized data needs to be submitted back to the server, the values from the first instance would have to be copied into the corresponding fields in the second instance. If what I said here is true, having to have several "xforms:model"s for each form complicates the forms authoring too much. Thank you, Martin.
Received on Monday, 28 January 2002 11:17:33 UTC