- From: Aaron Reed <aaronr@us.ibm.com>
- Date: Wed, 9 May 2007 19:01:21 -0500
- To: www-forms-editor@w3.org
- Message-ID: <OFD35F2713.8B2B1988-ON872572D6.008061A6-862572D6.0083A094@us.ibm.com>
The last of my last call comments. Covers section 11. 1) 11.1 - I'd reword the last sentence of the description for @mode, especially the last section of the sentence after the ','. 2) 11.1 - What are the valid possible values for @verb? Not mentioned in the schema. What is a 'submission protocol verb'? Do you mean that it overrides @method? 3) 11.1 - I'd suggest that the end of section 11.1 (before 11.2) is a good place to list the 'worker elements' that can appear as children since this information can't be found in the schema. 4) 11.2 - extraneous ')' in the second sentence. 5) 11.2 - #2 - So even if @relevant="false", we can't bind xf:submission to a non-relevant node? That seems counter-intuitive. 6) 11.2 - second bullet after #8 - Missed capitalizing 'if' which starts the sentence, "If the parse fails, then submission processing concludes..." 7) 11.7.2 - the first sentence doesn't make sense. Perhaps it should read, "The submission element can optionally <contain> a child element named verb..." 8) 11.8 - what about header information that might be determined also by other things? Like charset? Does that also override? What if header information is duplicated? 9) 11.8.1 - also other places where the new worker elements live - what if @value is an invalid xpath expression? No xforms-compute-exception? Or any other kind of error? 10) 11.9 - the sentence right before the serialization table - the word 'attribute' is duplicated. 11) 11.12 - third bullet - extraneous 'as' in "Element nodes selected for includesion are as encoded as ..." 12) 11.19.3 - fifth bullet - should probably be 'changed', not 'change' in "...header is change to text/xml" Good luck finishing up the 1.1 work! --Aaron IBM Corporation Internal Zip: 9022D016 11501 Burnet Road Austin, TX 78758 (512)838-9948 inet: aaronr@us.ibm.com _ (} @ |= Volleyball Rules!!! /\
Received on Thursday, 10 May 2007 00:01:36 UTC