Fwd: New Invited Expert policy for Working and Interest Groups

This achives 2 things:
- put the announcement to Chairs from last Friday into a public archive
- give an opportunity to address some public requests for a summary of 
differences in public

Announcement is at the end.

Diffs from previous version:

1- Allow invited experts to access the same level of information than 
other group participants from the W3C Membership.

   Previously, access to the Member website was not granted to invited 
experts unless exception. The new policy turns this around.

2- Require that the status of invited expert for an individual in a 
Group is reconsidered when a Group gets rechartered.

  While there was an expectation for a periodic review in the past, such 
review were not really happening appropriately. The new policy anchors 
those reviews at rechartering time and requires Chairs and Team Contacts 
to be explicit about those.

Philippe

-------- Forwarded Message --------
Subject: New Invited Expert policy
Date: Fri, 21 Jul 2023 10:23:40 -0400
From: Philippe Le Hégaret <plh@w3.org>

Dear Chairs,

Following a recommendation from the Advisory Board in March [1], we have 
updated our invited expert policy.

[[
All IEs are invited to participate for the terms of the current 
Charter(s) for the group(s) the IE will be associated with, except that 
provisional invitations granted to “membership candidate” organizations 
may have shorter terms. Additionally, Chairs may in exceptional 
circumstances give Invited Experts a term shorter than the remaining 
charter duration.

When a Charter expires, Chairs and Team Contacts must explicitly review 
all IEs within that group. If a Group is allowed to continue meeting 
after the Charter has expired, the IEs in that group will also be 
extended until the group is formally closed or the Charter is renewed. 
The Chairs and Team Contacts should determine if the IE’s expertise is 
still needed based on the scope of any new Charter. As part of the 
review, if the IE has stopped actively contributing to the group, their 
Invited Expert status should be terminated by the Chairs and Team 
Contact of the group.

By default, IEs are granted Member Access. At the discretion of the Team 
Contact, or at the request of the IE themselves, certain IEs may not be 
given Member Access. This option is required as there are some Invited 
Experts who have expressed that they do not wish to be, or are unable to 
be, responsible for managing Member Confidential information.

Additionally, on a case by case basis, a group may define in its charter 
that invitations to IEs will not include Member access. The Team may 
consult with the AB about when such restrictions are appropriate.

Once this policy is approved, IEs in existing groups will have their 
permissions upgraded upon rechartering, or earlier if requested by the 
group’s Chairs.
]]
https://github.com/w3c/AB-memberonly/issues/3#issuecomment-1452850917

Our systems have been revised to apply this new policy.

Public documentation integrating the new policy is at:
   https://www.w3.org/invited-experts/#review

As a reminder, you can check the status of your invited experts from the 
participants page of your working group. For example, for the EOWG:

[[
Chairs and W3C Team can review the Invited Expert applications for this 
group.
]]
https://www.w3.org/groups/wg/eowg/participants/

  -> https://www.w3.org/groups/wg/eowg/invited-experts/


Thank you,

Philippe

PS: feel free to forward this message in a public archive for your Group.

Received on Wednesday, 26 July 2023 20:14:29 UTC