- From: Jan Nijtmans <Jan.Nijtmans@cmg.nl>
- Date: Thu, 28 May 1998 08:15:09 -0400 (EDT)
- To: www-amaya@w3.org
At first, I would like to mention that Amaya is a nice piece of
work. I mainly use it as HTML-editor, because it is guaranteed
to produce HTML-4 compilant code. Still I would like to report
some problems that I found during the past weeks. I am mainly
using version 1.2a on Windows NT 4.0. I checked the mail
archive, but I didn't find other reports with the same remarks.
* Proxy use on Windows NT4.0
When I add the following line to THOT.INI:
HTTP_PROXY=http://........... (our proxy server)
Amaya refuses to start. Without this line, Amaya
works fine, only I cannot conect to sites outside the
domain through the proxy server. With the earlier Amaya
1.2 binary distribution for Windows NT this worked fine.
* '>' or '>';
Stand-alone '>' characters in text are left as-is when
Amaya saves it to a file. Unfortunately Word 97 treats
this as an invalid character when reading HTML. I
suggest to follow the HTML 4.0 recommendation, as
described in the file charset.html:
Authors wishing to put the "<" character in text should use "<"
(ASCII decimal 60) to avoid possible confusion with the beginning
of a tag (start tag open delimiter). Similarly, authors should use
">" (ASCII decimal 62) in text instead of ">" to avoid problems
with older user agents that incorrectly perceive this as the end of
a tag (tag close delimiter) when it appears in quoted attribute
values.
Word 97 is not really 'old', but it has this bug as well. And
even worse: it happens everywhere, not only in quoted attribute
values. When does Microsoft learn................ :-(
* Form editing inside tables.
When adding a form element (e.g. <input>) to a page, Amaya checks if
this element is within a <form>. If not, Amaya adds the required
<form>
tags automatically. But in the following example this goes wrong:
<form ....>
<table ...>
<tbody>
<tr>
<td>cel 1
</td>
<tr>
<tbody>
</table>
</form>
When trying to place an <input> element into cel 1, a <form> tag pair
is added as well. This is undesired because the page already has one.
* table border
When loading a file containing <table>'s without the border attribute,
Amaya
automatically changes this to <table border=1>. A document table which
orriginally has no border suddenly has.
Looking forward to the next version of Amaya, in which those problems
are hopefully solved. Thanks for the great work.
--
Jan Nijtmans, CMG (Computer Management Group) Arnhem B.V.
email: Jan.Nijtmans@wxs.nl (private)
Jan.Nijtmans@cmg.nl (work)
url: http://home.wxs.nl/~nijtmans/
Received on Thursday, 28 May 1998 08:16:47 UTC