- From: Janina Sajka <janina@rednote.net>
- Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2009 11:59:01 -0400
- To: WAI XTech <wai-xtech@w3.org>
Minutes from today's HTML Caucus teleconference are provided below in text, and are available in html at: http://www.w3.org/2009/10/16-pf-minutes.html W3C - DRAFT - PF/HTML_Caucus telecon 16 Oct 2009 See also: IRC log Attendees Present Cynthia_Shelly, Janina, Cooper, Rich Regrets Chair Janina_Sajka Scribe janina Contents * Topics * Summary of Action Items __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ <scribe> agenda: this <Stevef> Recommendations regarding Long Text Alternatives http://www.w3.org/2009/06/Text-Alternatives-in-HTML5 <cyns> SF: alt text. I looked back at the wai concensus doc, and it reflected what I was saying in the WAI PF meeting yesterday <cyns> RS: I hate longdesc <cyns> JS: I think we agreed to obsolete longdesc <cyns> SF: that path requires behavior for aria-described-by that weren't agreed to by ppl like Rich <cyns> RS: in the accessibiltiy API, all described by is is a relationship that will take you somewhere in your doc, anywhere you want it to. I hate the idea of putting a link in there and forcing the browser to take the link. <cyns> JS: force, or offer to the browser? <cyns> SF: I thought it was just an offer <cyns> RS: ok, that's better. <cyns> SF: in the case where the longdesc has ref and id that's on a link, and the link text is further description, provide a mechnaism for the user to be albe to navigate teh link. A mechnanism whereby te user can move to the structured content <cyns> RS: no problem with taht <cyns> SF: a number of ID references could be a problem. Describedby is just supposed to concatenate text from multiple references. <cyns> RS: if the content is hidden, tehre's nowhere to go to. it'll be in the dom but not in teh API <cyns> RS: if it's hidden, UA will fill in MSAA description with whatever text it can gleen. It's like help text, can work with tooltip or whatever. But, the current interface in JAWS provides a mechanism to go to the descriptin. <cyns> SF: The way to go there needs to be specked out for the AT vendor. <cyns> JS: because longdesc was not a success <cyns> RS: what about if there's more than one IDREF for description? That's not spec'd, and needs to be. <cyns> SF: we could provide a set of steps. EG if the ID is on a table, move to table, if it's on a link provide an option to activate the link, if it's just a text container, just read out the content. <cyns> MC: just allow normal processing, just go to the described by section. if there's a link, the user can click/activate it. <cyns> RS: we can't make AT vendors do it. <cyns> CS; no w3c specs for AT, hole <cyns> RS: there is history, reasons for this. <cyns> RS: AT vendors wouldn't follow first UAAG spec <cyns> SF; need to revisist what we've said in text alternative document <cyns> SF: provide idea in implementiaon guide on how we think AT should implement it. <cyns> CS: put AT guidelines in UAG? or separate doc? good idea, but increase in scope <cyns> RS: good luck getting them to do it. <cyns> CS: took 10 years with browsers, maybe time to start with AT? <cyns> JS; existing mechanism (longdesc) is a failure, look at why, build from that <cyns> SF: some AT and browser vendors did implement longdesc <cyns> SF: if we provide a better mechanism, they may implement it. <cyns> JS: part of why we like ability to point via href via aria-describedby, is that we could do various media, not just text <cyns> SF: if you have a long text alternative relationship, if there are 1 or 10 things you're pointing to, the user can get access to those things <cyns> JS: jst like any 1 or 10 hrefs on a web page, no a special case <cyns> RS: can you give me an example where you'd need more than one described-by? <cyns> SF: one image that's more than one table? A graph, a data table in html that provides the data, that's the sort of relationship that a user would want to know about <cyns> CS: multiple alternative versions for cognitive, like a picture, a video, a shorter version of the text, etc. <cyns> RS: so, we need to say that if there are multiple IDREFs, each is an alternative description. AT can then bring up a list box, and you can pick the one you want. <cyns> SF: agree <cyns> JS: list should tell you want mime type it is <cyns> RS: would have to be in a target <cyns> CS: sounds like a may <cyns> JS: I'd accept a MAY, or a SHOULD <cyns> RS; do we want to put in in the spec? <cyns> what about mainstream UA? should we ask them to do that? <cyns> CS: yes, I think so <cyns> RS: in the spec, make that a should or a may for now. When IE or FF does it, HTML5 will follow <cyns> resolved: Multiple IDREF in an aria-describedby MUST be interpreted as multiple alternative rendereings, AT and other UA may expose mime-type to the user, non-AT UA SHOULD provide a mechanism for navigating to the IDREF <cyns> RESOLVED: Multiple IDREF in an aria-describedby MUST be interpreted as multiple alternative rendereings, AT and other UA may expose mime-type to the user, non-AT UA SHOULD provide a mechanism for navigating to the IDREF <scribe> scribe: janina js: open agenda today, any topics for us? rs: someone should be designated to start submitting changes from our spread sheet cs: the mappings? rs: yes, we're taking ian's and redoing it, so create an issue, make this change, etc cs: i was thinking putting the entire table in as a change request rs: were you planning to cover this on aria call? cs: could rs: should probably run on the aria group cs: didn't we decide this at our f2f? js: for our santa clara f2f? cs: would like to get it to html wg before then ... at the very least i'd like to have this ready to submit by f2f rs: i'll try to add some of the external dependencies cs: frank fro ie team working on a canvas proposal, related, needs rich's guidance rs: is there likely to be an html6 on the heels of html5? cs: certainly a discussion rs: instrumenting an a11y api for html5 will be almost impossible -- re canvas ... we can add dom, but that's aria2 -- cs: canvas is so different from html Summary of Action Items Present: Cynthia_Shelly Janina Cooper Rich -- Janina Sajka, Phone: +1.202.595.7777; sip:janina@CapitalAccessibility.Com Partner, Capital Accessibility LLC http://CapitalAccessibility.Com Marketing the Owasys 22C talking screenless cell phone in the U.S. and Canada Learn more at http://ScreenlessPhone.Com Chair, Open Accessibility janina@a11y.org Linux Foundation http://a11y.org Chair, Protocols & Formats Web Accessibility Initiative http://www.w3.org/wai/pf World Wide Web Consortium (W3C)
Received on Friday, 16 October 2009 15:59:35 UTC