Feedback to Shared Web Experiences

Per request from EOWG to WCAG WG to provide feedback to the "Shared Web Experience" document, please see below for my feedback.

 

In general, I found the document well structured for comprehension.  But I have been working on WCAG too long to speak on this without bias.

 

Ø  Is it clear what information is provided in each document, and where to get other related information?

o    There is clearly an "n-to-n" relationship between MWBP & WCAG.  It would be helpful if we provide a mapping of this relationship.  The document "From MWBP to WCAG 1&2" and "From WCAG 1&2 to MWBP" are helpful, but it assumes that the author has finished working on WCAG or MWBP.  That is not necessarily true.  I believe the "WCAG 2 & MWBP together" document would be of more help for most practical purposes.  Please cover the "n-to-n" relationship in the "WCAG 2 & MWBP together" document.

o    I'd suggest to remove the WCAG 1 document to promote adoption of WCAG 2.

o    Not that I have any clever idea, but title of document "From MWBP to WCAG x" and the like can be improved.

o    Similar to the above comment, I think the title of "nothing", "something", and "everything" somewhat unclear.  I agree this is a difficult concept to convey in a single word.  If I think of better idea, I'd let you know.

Ø  In the "Shared Web Experiences" document, is the detailed information clear yet succinct?

o    As a WCAG WG member, this document is clear enough to me.  But I don't know if that would be the same in the MWBP group.

o    A number of WCAG 2 success criteria are missing from the document.  I assume that is due to the incomplete status of the document.

Ø  Are there other examples that we might want to include in the "Shared Web Experiences" document?

o    I think it would unhelpful to cover all possible scenarios here.  Use the best case forward is fine.  It would also cut down the length of document as well.

 

All best,

Alex Li 
Manager, Accessibility Standards and Policies 
SAP Labs, Inc. 
3410 Hillview Ave 
Palo Alto, CA 94304 
T (650) 687-4770 
F (610) 492-2961 
M (202) 492-4592 
mailto: alex.li@sap.com <mailto:alex.li@sap.com>  
http://www.sap.com <http://www.sap.com/>  
THE BEST-RUN BUSINESSES RUN SAP 
This e-mail is confidential and may contain privileged information. If you are not the addressee it may be unlawful for you to read, copy, distribute, disclose or otherwise use the information in this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient please notify us immediately.