Re: Acceptance Criteria for proposals for new Success Criteria

Jason,
Thanks for the edits.

2.Be testable through automated or manual processes.
[Jason] They should be as reliably testable as possible, while achieving their intended purpose and benefit.

Why is this significant?  If a criterion doesn’t achieve the intended purpose then it won’t be accepted.

6.Apply to all content, unless specific exceptions are included in the success criteria (e.g. "except interruptions involving an emergency").
[Jason] Where a success criterion applies to only some types of content or only under specific conditions, such conditions should be stated explicitly (e.g., “If non-text content is time-based media”).

I think that your change says the same thing, but doesn’t work with the structure of the prompt, so leaving as is.

7.Apply across technologies to the extent possible. (Technology-specific issues should usually be addressed in Techniques.)
[Jason] Should read “to the greatest extent possible”.

Changed.

8.Avoid creating a requirement for something that is already required by an existing Success Criteria.
[Jason] Should read “criterion” at the end of the sentence.

Changed.

9.Have Success Techniques which demonstrate that the Success Criteria is reasonable and implementable, using common formats, user agents, and assistive technologies.
[Jason] Should read “the success criterion is”.

Changed to “each success criterion is”

Thanks,
AWK