Re: 1.3.5 Identify Input Purpose Level AA (added in 2.1) - Sufficient technique(s)

Thanks much for taking the time to let us know, David.

I've created a bug issue:
 https://github.com/w3c/wai-wcag-quickref/issues/247

Hopefully we can get to fix it soon.

~Shawn

On 06-Nov-23 7:00 AM, David Berman wrote:
> Hi Shawn,
> 
> It was great seeing you in Washington last month!
> 
> I think we've found an inconsistency in the WCAG 2.1 guidance:
> For 1.3.5, the sufficient technique is /not /listed here (and should be) (i.e. there is no expand for sufficient techniques the way there is on e for 1.3.6 (see screen capture below):
> https://www.w3.org/WAI/WCAG21/quickref/?showtechniques=136#identify-input-purpose 
> <https://u5854113.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=ECoEsZIblaBK6NDP073Ml7LsSZOBSPxfN-2BglxWf6Lchdmb3xtEerL1TpL5TrKcEUnEJo-2Fa3s8rinKIVl4g1zSJLCGzzRsIfwY3-2BjCs0qs9NpjGhSfei3jK9J8zQGIRqbKgZPeJikYFYAfwSu5IOZ5vZa-2F-2Fyz4f52NIzegI6c3-2B3RyEDYuCve1wlWVAR433gbLb54MiaWyAIkJlU3V8-2FwE5VmzWLJiGOtHnDetN7hB2lXg5TVHEw4-2BARA1kS4t56ZoHp6gOp-2F6fU0shSrv13FhhJESdJQWq66OR4fhsjnyJsbi7LVbCmVYfQ5hpC3nU5SsPqehHziEFrarkRXbgacHFafs-2BpUeV-2F2vsjFsYmhDLvWamg0wEs4zy62IByA2lb0Pq34hJWEnVd7rQrdcNnWCPF81jVn35hu5vCOaZF-2BdjiTFvXKjhvtgUKuXm3oxLPU-2BbPqkfaPYW58SuERD3Mvghoq8kGX0TDyeqbAP-2FUcsuoJl7rmvaBYI7-2F9gvc6gIav3STsynfzltHZUIvLZG9IKBP0VYrcvJ-2FrnUW51d2DDi9S0fa-2FoS3-2FN3L6DlAWBjdaJRw0BEV8hP9WPVqZ75D9Ofc7noWVi3I1cAQCCTg2V0A-3DPP-x_lm7JlFoCR5OuD7-2BdMtSXPbUBA2ZEQW-2BuFF9arHjCVNSQKtVA8xMYjLDPvFNyyCo4Fgr0uG7SeC9QLpor28hVHtBEt2by0Q4KcZsVa9XT8bVAGxL91MJt8Hd7apQX16A6VknUdcBuYv2WbM-2BQfY0B-2BtVabxoP6qNXWQGhRe1RvOFvHq3HTVnJk8fBLc36mEuemPw-2FzoPWBdQaSGBk2UpdzA-3D-3D>
> 
> image.png
> 
> 
> ... even though a sufficient technique exists (and people may not look here):
> 
>     https://www.w3.org/WAI/WCAG21/Understanding/identify-input-purpose.html <https://u5854113.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=ECoEsZIblaBK6NDP073Ml7LsSZOBSPxfN-2BglxWf6Lchdmb3xtEerL1TpL5TrKcEUnEJo-2Fa3s8rinKIVl4g1zSJLCGzzRsIfwY3-2BjCs0qs9NpjGhSfei3jK9J8zQGIRqbA2-2FiCOee6rTY5GNGkIXsRccmV0v3rg667NmhgFhuMncKYDPkghq4EXa-2BU5ChJ4z4In4Mmdp1prVoVTZSyOEUXtY2C4-2FxQJu8xYZc0scbwWgtNgGK7YcOxY2bgYV4MXuNlmFxr4ifIqYfRxBiRSPwfmIzx-2Fo-2FOmRUKQNy18XgY2W-2BPoDsQlGQK6HHk9iyp08jfzEZrZdfzqQ-2FUMnG13-2Fo6OO9-2B7Gvqgo-2BQPb9ZCQjc-2Bxbkw3UYxRNhluxLFxp7P2taqVG0tywQ5vyXKBxA7-2FLUssOk-2BcWLs7PkcE2zR6vcHLdBtTIoCHRbnJqRFaCraKBielRu22n0a4h2k2Zb-2FFfNALRzlkwWnjFGkjhjcxDfZP2QEvuZJ31qMiQK85qJdunu6paa7DK-2FBDrQOpMtm0gpocITFVgpBgjyERKw0lXZEazVBzva0j9XtCWVZrxr-2BGjXXgX_lm7JlFoCR5OuD7-2BdMtSXPbUBA2ZEQW-2BuFF9arHjCVNSQKtVA8xMYjLDPvFNyyCo4QxMpTLO7mAI8TToYgrcME3a1dvhTIwxWcCJ1dNn00Ft-2ByoZhQ0CP3uMB3KlHWtjtFXh62jM6igDPHoq1tjJOE-2Fgz-2BmhnOrkYBcaKVHK-2FHCUQ7oTl7TLkN5kOOpEi-2BFf29LDlL3HVqkTfGR4F5UPP0Q-3D-3D>
> 
> 
> -David
> 
> On Fri, 8 Jul 2022 at 17:33, Shawn Henry <shawn@w3.org <mailto:shawn@w3.org>> wrote:
> 
>     Hi EOWG,
> 
>     We're juggling review and publication schedule around European summer break. That means:
>     * Please complete the reviews soon.
>     * We will likely have less work for you in the coming few weeks, so you'll get a bit of a break.
> 
>     Two short reviews are needed now. One optional survey for COGA.
> 
>     See Work for this Week:
>     https://www.w3.org/WAI/EO/wiki/EOWG_Meetings#Reviews_and_Surveys <https://u5854113.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=ECoEsZIblaBK6NDP073MlzHyVBTYPNGza4HIPrdEwtUBdh60AutyEBNQoT9n8qA-2FtomZ8hA9skKttwczIHVh7n808G51mBdh-2FWvnI6R-2B3oA-3DJIJh_lm7JlFoCR5OuD7-2BdMtSXPbUBA2ZEQW-2BuFF9arHjCVNSQKtVA8xMYjLDPvFNyyCo49vl2BgV-2FqfSwnNPLvqjd4hioblrRl-2FulEVMC0TeMIR8-2F3oNle0-2BX5EypWtlWWn3PaQk8pm-2FuSA4y-2FthdPmwr7htE6mgV3E0YZ4gzjP6rv738ka-2FUgCE8klICAuS16Y9YPezlwxRKN-2FPGMa-2BUyAUtEA-3D-3D>
> 
>     Thanks much!
>     ~Shawn for EOWG Co-Chairs
> 
> 
> 
> -- 
> David Berman, RGD, FGDC, CPWA | LinkedIn | Slack
> David Berman Communications | berman@davidberman.com <mailto:berman@davidberman.com> | @davidberman
> +1-613-728-6777 | 340 Selby Avenue, Ottawa K2A 3X6

Received on Monday, 6 November 2023 14:43:17 UTC